Forums
Proposal: remove FMR.
Quick find code: 278-279-764-66212663
Mrs Ana
said
:
Yea, you can put 2 and 2 together to see who reported you and what for/why, but you can't see the contents of the reports. This ought to be protected at all costs for privacy/anonymity concerns. Just like the privacy and anonymity of regular users are protected on Forum Help?
Any accusations of bias or even revenge-moderation could then be raised on the renewed FMR thread, which would be up and running in an efficient manner. Win-win.
Yea, you can put 2 and 2 together to see who reported you and what for/why, but you can't see the contents of the reports. This ought to be protected at all costs for privacy/anonymity concerns. Just like the privacy and anonymity of regular users are protected on Forum Help?
Any accusations of bias or even revenge-moderation could then be raised on the renewed FMR thread, which would be up and running in an efficient manner. Win-win.
28-Oct-2021 15:53:33 - Last edited on 28-Oct-2021 15:54:42 by Nubby Nubnub
Dilbert2001
said
:
Jagex doesn't have to designate a single Jmod to handle FMR. I remember there was a time Mods Lee and Poerkie adjudicated FMR together. Of course, they can add Mods AI, Jagexa or the likes as many social media are already employing. Obviously, it's never one single J-Mod that's assigned to handle FMR. It's whomever forms part of the Community Management Team that may or may not deal with FMR. For example, Mod Hooli has been the Lead Community Manager since at least June, 2020 (See: HERE ) and he has never posted on FMR. Mod Miva has been a Senior Community Manager since June, 2021. Mod Miva hasn't been added to the Forums usergroup yet as you can't see their profile here. They also haven't reviewed FMR yet. As per Mod Kari's post here , this may all soon change.
For historical reference, when this version of FMR was active starting on January 4th, 2016 through May 21st, 2018, Forum Moderation Review , we had the following Jagex Moderators responding to reports there
:
Mod Kalaya
Mod Neena
Mod Shauny
Mod Balance (Head of Community at that time)
Mod Matthe
Mod Cam
Mod Meadows
Mod Poerkie
Mod Balance even engaged in reviewing reports there, which was welcomed because his position entailed many projects and responsibilities, just like Mod Hooli's duties at the moment. As evidenced above, it's clear that it's never one J-Mod assigned to review FMR. It's whomever forms part of Community Management that may or may not deal with concerns there. In the case of Mod Kari, she was the only one that formed part of the Forums community and was tasked with reviewing FMR and the Forum Mods. Since she has now departed, this task has been handed down to both Mod Hooli and Mod Miva.
Jagex doesn't have to designate a single Jmod to handle FMR. I remember there was a time Mods Lee and Poerkie adjudicated FMR together. Of course, they can add Mods AI, Jagexa or the likes as many social media are already employing. Obviously, it's never one single J-Mod that's assigned to handle FMR. It's whomever forms part of the Community Management Team that may or may not deal with FMR. For example, Mod Hooli has been the Lead Community Manager since at least June, 2020 (See: HERE ) and he has never posted on FMR. Mod Miva has been a Senior Community Manager since June, 2021. Mod Miva hasn't been added to the Forums usergroup yet as you can't see their profile here. They also haven't reviewed FMR yet. As per Mod Kari's post here , this may all soon change.
For historical reference, when this version of FMR was active starting on January 4th, 2016 through May 21st, 2018, Forum Moderation Review , we had the following Jagex Moderators responding to reports there
:
Mod Kalaya
Mod Neena
Mod Shauny
Mod Balance (Head of Community at that time)
Mod Matthe
Mod Cam
Mod Meadows
Mod Poerkie
Mod Balance even engaged in reviewing reports there, which was welcomed because his position entailed many projects and responsibilities, just like Mod Hooli's duties at the moment. As evidenced above, it's clear that it's never one J-Mod assigned to review FMR. It's whomever forms part of Community Management that may or may not deal with concerns there. In the case of Mod Kari, she was the only one that formed part of the Forums community and was tasked with reviewing FMR and the Forum Mods. Since she has now departed, this task has been handed down to both Mod Hooli and Mod Miva.
28-Oct-2021 16:27:49
Nubby Nubnub
said
:
Mrs Ana said :
Yea, you can put 2 and 2 together to see who reported you and what for/why, but you can't see the contents of the reports. This ought to be protected at all costs for privacy/anonymity concerns. Just like the privacy and anonymity of regular users are protected on Forum Help?
Any accusations of bias or even revenge-moderation could then be raised on the renewed FMR thread, which would be up and running in an efficient manner. Win-win. Forum Help is there for transparency/openess where Forum Moderation Review is there for more difficult cases, making posts hidden is to prevent issues from returning in circular continuous movements of issues, where issues sustain being hard to solve or to end.
Mrs Ana said :
Yea, you can put 2 and 2 together to see who reported you and what for/why, but you can't see the contents of the reports. This ought to be protected at all costs for privacy/anonymity concerns. Just like the privacy and anonymity of regular users are protected on Forum Help?
Any accusations of bias or even revenge-moderation could then be raised on the renewed FMR thread, which would be up and running in an efficient manner. Win-win. Forum Help is there for transparency/openess where Forum Moderation Review is there for more difficult cases, making posts hidden is to prevent issues from returning in circular continuous movements of issues, where issues sustain being hard to solve or to end.
28-Oct-2021 16:30:54
@Dilbert2001:
I'm referring to the process of reviewing FMR throughout the years, as that's what the thread's topic is. There has never been just one J-Mod assigned to FMR since reviewing FMR, taking care of the Forums and Forum Mods, for that matter, it's already included in the duties and responsibilities of every member of Community Management (See: Head of CM - Q&A ). In Mod Kari's case, she was the only one assigned to such a role, but it didn't mean that Mod Hooli couldn't step in. As we know, we expect Mod Hooli and/or Mod Miva to fill in her shoes
.
I'm referring to the process of reviewing FMR throughout the years, as that's what the thread's topic is. There has never been just one J-Mod assigned to FMR since reviewing FMR, taking care of the Forums and Forum Mods, for that matter, it's already included in the duties and responsibilities of every member of Community Management (See: Head of CM - Q&A ). In Mod Kari's case, she was the only one assigned to such a role, but it didn't mean that Mod Hooli couldn't step in. As we know, we expect Mod Hooli and/or Mod Miva to fill in her shoes
.
28-Oct-2021 17:09:32
Quick find code: 278-279-764-66212663 Back to Top