I really like the idea of a new skill but Sailing is not it. To me, it sounds more like a minigame combined with a variety of existing skills (Construction, Smithing, Farming) and RS3 skills (Dungeoneering, which IMO hardly is a skill in the first place).
I wanted to be persuaded by this but I find myself dissapointed in what you're suggesting. Also you've massively ripped off ideas from Zelda: Wind Waker.
Such a shame.
14-Aug-2015 22:30:52