Forums

LGBT Thread is locked

Quick find code: 23-24-393-65913078

The contents of this message have been hidden.

18-Nov-2017 23:58:26

Lumine

Lumine

Posts: 15,239 Opal Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
Dong U Dead said :
People often say just be 'gay' without the 'coming out of the closet'


Given that 'coming out' means telling other people that you're gay, the only way to be gay without coming out would be never to tell anybody. Which might make finding partners rather difficult :P - and does, of course, for those who aren't out yet.

But it's hardly something that most people would want to be the case for their entire lives. That's going back to the days where no-one was allowed to be out at all.

Dong U Dead said :
The thing people don't understand you are not abused for being straight, you are not beaten up for being straight, you are not killed for being straight, you are not thought of differently for being straight - no one gives it a second thought for being straight and I bet if the LGBTQ could have a life like this they would, they would love it


Exactly. It's not the truth that "no-one cares if you're gay, so just stop going on about it." Plenty of people care that you're gay, and want to make you feel bad about it, from treating you as a disgusting being to kicking you out of home to beating you up to murdering you.

Banding together and shouting "We exist, and we're not going away, and we're not going to let you intimidate us, and we like being us and are proud of being us, so back off!!" is exactly the reaction you'd expect to that range of threats. It's not a threat to others that they are standing up against being threatened themselves.
Lumine
Patrona Emerita
of the
Caped Carousers
quest cape clan
93-94-178-66118830

19-Nov-2017 01:14:19

Chiburu

Chiburu

Posts: 259 Silver Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
I'd like to add something that some straight people need to understand, and as a general thing for everyone of which to be aware.

I have met and known many straight individuals who claim to support LGBT, but then blindly say, "I don't care if you're gay."

Here's the problem with those two sentiments. You support something, but you don't care? Why would you support something you don't care about? And if you truly did care, you support it because it would matter to you—or if not to you, to the people you care about. Keep reading!!

I completely accept anyone who simply doesn't care about LGBT, and, thus, has no opinion
whether they see it or not.
I also accept anyone who doesn't like LGBT
, because that'd be hypocritical on my behalf to force something that's solely my opinion on someone else. I've had my fair share of personal advocating with personal relationships, which could explain my previous post. As long as those people don't act upon their disliking and treat others worse, differing worldviews are fair.
What I don't accept is
when I'm around people who say they don't care if someone's gay and then say they fully support the movement, because those kinds of people are the very ones who believe homosexuality is being shoved in the public's face, rather than conditioning homosexuality to be a normal thing—which is what I believe should be happening. What would they know about something they support when they don't bother to care and research?

This message can be said to anyone about anything.
Never support something you claim not to care about.
You will most likely contradict yourself. And if you are one of those people who use "don't care" with "support" but are genuinely okay with it, change your word choice. Like during political voting, if you don't care about politics, you'll vote for anything, so just don't vote.
(In Australia, though, you have to vote, otherwise you will be fined.)
Artist
|
Animator
|
Programmer
|
Writer
...and most importantly...
|
Gamer
|

19-Nov-2017 03:06:39 - Last edited on 19-Nov-2017 09:28:02 by Chiburu

Dong U Dead

Dong U Dead

Posts: 29,016 Sapphire Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
@Chiburu, maybe they don't mean it in the way you are perceiving the words 'don't care'?? Maybe it's if your straight, gay, trans, bi etc it makes no difference to them, you are still you no matter what your sexual orientation is?? It's not that they don't care as i am sure they do...

- It's kinda like the saying sticks and stones may break my bones but words will never hurt me <- that's a load of hog wash, words hurt and so do stones and sticks - it doesn't matter if the words, stones, and sticks come from someone you care/love, or a complete stranger or someone you just don't like - it's hurts no matter what, some more so than others possibly?
If fat means flavour then I'm ******* delicious!

19-Nov-2017 03:56:33

Chiburu

Chiburu

Posts: 259 Silver Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
Dong U Dead said :
@Chiburu, maybe they don't mean it in the way you are perceiving the words 'don't care'?? Maybe it's if your straight, gay, trans, bi etc it makes no difference to them, you are still you no matter what your sexual orientation is?? It's not that they don't care as i am sure they do...
Yes, you're definitely on to something, which is why I encourage them to choose a better phrase other than "I don't care if you're gay", so they can better understand what they're saying, and that others don't misinterpret them.

My main concern is when those very people turn around and start saying, "I don't care if you're gay, but I don't think you should be forcing us to see gay things all the time ", which, I would think, shows that they do care in a negative light.


This can be easily turned around when gay people describe themselves as "straight acting". Just as there are many kinds of straight males (where some make sure they're masculine and attractive, etc.), there are also many kinds of gay males (where some make sure their sexual orientation is the highest trait, etc.). It saddens me that gays who see themselves not as ones who wear makeup or have a feminine fashion sense feel the need to use the label "straight" as a trait in the gay community, because then that simply reciprocates the very thing we don't want—similar to the insult "you throw like a girl", where being a female is seen as weak or unsuitable. I am probably the most boring type of homosexual male, where I don't like makeup, or have a keen sense of fashion, or even a stereotypical lisp (as far as I know, haha!), no matter how I portray myself atypical to the usual spectrum within a sexual orientation, I'm still going to consider myself gay. And even on a day-to-day basis, the need to remind people or myself that I am a gay individual hardly comes to mind as any sort of significant feature.
Artist
|
Animator
|
Programmer
|
Writer
...and most importantly...
|
Gamer
|

19-Nov-2017 05:16:30 - Last edited on 19-Nov-2017 09:00:03 by Chiburu

Dong U Dead

Dong U Dead

Posts: 29,016 Sapphire Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
My late son was gay, he first told me when he was 18, well he told me he was bi - which shocked me a bit as I thought he was gay. Couple of years later he told me he was gay not bi. I had known way before he told me and I am certainly not a hard person to tell and I certainly gave him plenty of oppotunities to inform me - he chose to when I had moved down south miles and miles away from him over the phone ^_^ I am not sure why he chose that moment. Anyway me looking and talking to him, well most people wouldn't have known he was gay - he was just the typical Kiwi guy. He loved skiing and jumping out of planes, hiking, camping and walking very, very, very long distances and he thanks me for that - as when he was growing up I use to make him walk, very, very long distances :D He talked like any guy would talk, he walked like any guy and dressed like any guy, he wasn't into makeup and dresses, he was just a typical guy who was attracted to other men. It was his busines, nobody elses.
If fat means flavour then I'm ******* delicious!

19-Nov-2017 05:43:55

Chiburu

Chiburu

Posts: 259 Silver Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
Dong U Dead said :
My late son was gay, he first told me when he was 18, well he told me he was bi - which shocked me a bit as I thought he was gay. Couple of years later he told me he was gay not bi. I had known way before he told me and I am certainly not a hard person to tell and I certainly gave him plenty of oppotunities to inform me - he chose to when I had moved down south miles and miles away from him over the phone ^_^ I am not sure why he chose that moment. [...]

I would have to reason that the distance of not needing to come out face-to-face was much less stressful for your son, so when he and you finally gained that comfortable distance, he was able to gain that courage to tell you. It's great to know that you are a very accepting and that you love your son no matter what. ^_^

My story isn't all too special. Long story short, I came out to my father by complete accident. He and I had a father-and-son breakfast, and we'd been talking about how life was going. It slowly transitioned into relationships, and then, next thing I knew, I told him. It took the both of us by surprise, because, like many closeted gays, I had no intention of telling my father, especially knowing what kind of a person he is, which would be incredibly off-topic to discuss here. The air was thick with unanswered questions and thoughts and feelings, but at the end of the day, all he asked of me was to be the son he raised me to be. I never thought it would have gone that way, but I'm very thankful and fortunate it went the way it had. I know a few people personally who weren't so lucky. :(
Artist
|
Animator
|
Programmer
|
Writer
...and most importantly...
|
Gamer
|

19-Nov-2017 07:13:10 - Last edited on 19-Nov-2017 07:14:18 by Chiburu

Raleirosen

Raleirosen

Posts: 5,069 Rune Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
Chiburu said :
Yes, you're definitely on to something, which is why I encourage them to choose a better phrase other than "I don't care if you're gay", so they can better understand what they're saying, and that others don't misinterpret them.
Or you could get over yourself and stop misinterpreting. It's perfectly possible to support equal treatment of LGBT without caring about individual people who identify as LGBT, in the same way that people endorse equal treatment of blacks, women, etc. without gushing about how much they care about individual minorities. When people say they don't care if you're gay, they're probably aligning themselves with principles and values that transcend immutable characteristics like sexual orientation and skin color -- you know, the better parts of humanity.

If you insist on rejecting support that doesn't meet your pointless purity test, you might as well move to an Islamic theocracy for all the progress you're going to enact.
Patrolling Lore FC almost makes you wish for a Great Revision.

19-Nov-2017 07:14:07

Chiburu

Chiburu

Posts: 259 Silver Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
Raleirosen said :
Or you could get over yourself and stop misinterpreting. It's perfectly possible to support equal treatment of LGBT without caring about individual people who identify as LGBT, in the same way that people endorse equal treatment of blacks, women, etc. without gushing about how much they care about individual minorities. When people say they don't care if you're gay, they're probably aligning themselves with principles and values that transcend immutable characteristics like sexual orientation and skin color -- you know, the better parts of humanity.

If you insist on rejecting support that doesn't meet your pointless purity test, you might as well move to an Islamic theocracy for all the progress you're going to enact.
I never said I reject their support, nor do I have some kind of checklist for every straight person I meet. I also very clearly discussed in confidence that I don't usually engage in gay rights movements. I also elaborated on what you're trying to take out of context, so I'm not sure where you're getting your anger from.

However, I have met more than a handful of people who say the very thing I talked about, and then follow up later with homophobic or inappropriate remarks that come across as a gestural "shut the hell up already". Those are the people I'm talking about. I'd suggest you read more carefully my other posts, and not just snippets of a sentence or two, so that you can better tear me apart with more accurate opinions should you continue to do so.
Artist
|
Animator
|
Programmer
|
Writer
...and most importantly...
|
Gamer
|

19-Nov-2017 07:19:10 - Last edited on 19-Nov-2017 07:25:24 by Chiburu

Quick find code: 23-24-393-65913078 Back to Top