Forums
Inactive Clan Owners
Quick find code: 86-87-286-65225376
@ Mod Matthe
Ah I see! Well, about that I don't think there's a lot to discuss. If a leader is inactive that means he cannot take care of his clan anymore so either another high rank person takes the lead (warlord/council/whoever is capable of leading) or people quit for another clan. To be honest I never had any problem like that before, be it in international clans like Corruption, warring Team like Supremacy/TKO Blitz, or my clans - if a ranked person went inactive we simply called our mobiles/contacted him via msn/forums/facebook. I don't know about "in-game made" clans. And about cc managining - few people should be able to have main admin powers, so they can remove inactive leader. I don't know, maybe this feature is already in game.
Ah I see! Well, about that I don't think there's a lot to discuss. If a leader is inactive that means he cannot take care of his clan anymore so either another high rank person takes the lead (warlord/council/whoever is capable of leading) or people quit for another clan. To be honest I never had any problem like that before, be it in international clans like Corruption, warring Team like Supremacy/TKO Blitz, or my clans - if a ranked person went inactive we simply called our mobiles/contacted him via msn/forums/facebook. I don't know about "in-game made" clans. And about cc managining - few people should be able to have main admin powers, so they can remove inactive leader. I don't know, maybe this feature is already in game.
03-Dec-2013 18:05:36 - Last edited on 03-Dec-2013 18:08:31 by iMatzz
I like this idea, an inactive leader can't lead a clan so if a clan leader doesn't login for an x amount of days then he/she should be demoted, not kicked since many people value their clan xp, all progress is lost, orts and so on. The new owner can always kick or derank the ex-leader anyways.
I also agree on a removal when the owner gets perm banned.
Just like MsSantaPawsy said, the amount of days before someone's considered can make or break this. If it's too short it will annoy people but if it's too long and the ownership rank gets tranfered to another inactive deputy then it can lead to a lot of trouble..
I also like the idea of having a "senior rank"
Choobokka said :
Don't know if that's remotely workable, but support the idea of automating deputy's ability to make the change, but not automating the change itself.
A lot of things to think about and discuss
I also agree on a removal when the owner gets perm banned.
Just like MsSantaPawsy said, the amount of days before someone's considered can make or break this. If it's too short it will annoy people but if it's too long and the ownership rank gets tranfered to another inactive deputy then it can lead to a lot of trouble..
I also like the idea of having a "senior rank"
Choobokka said :
Don't know if that's remotely workable, but support the idea of automating deputy's ability to make the change, but not automating the change itself.
A lot of things to think about and discuss
03-Dec-2013 18:10:14
Amryine
said
:
Blair said :
Kicking seems a little harsh seeing as they are the Clan Owner, maybe demote to something like deputy leader instead?
Also, how will the automated system pick the new Leader?
The first Co-Owner should be promoted by seniority.
Esploratore said :
No support for an automated system to remove inactive clan leaders. The time to develop this would be better used in other clan-related areas.
Clans take so much work to build up and the thought of some automated system determining a clan's fate just doesn't seem right.
If JaGex can't work with the clans that have an inactive owner on an ad hoc basis, they shouldn't intervene at all, imo. I fully agree with this sentiment however. Instead of demoting or removing anyone though, just putting the original owner(s) on the fly (a list of "senior owners"
would suffice. When one returned, they would be able to be instantly re-instated. Depending how "high up", all the way to the original Owner, would be able to resume command over somebody added to the "senior" list based on tenure of the Co-Owner, then Deputy Owner spots. If there are NO players remaining in either of those lists, the clan should be considered disbanded, and removed from the game.
That's the best scenario I can come up with right now. It's fair, if you feel you MUST have a system. I don't think it's anyone's place however to do this. I just think there needs to be a BETTER idea conceived to remove inactive clans. Clan:
Demote the inactive leader after sai leader fails to log into the game for 45 calendar days, IMO.
6 Months, no less, no more.
Blair said :
Kicking seems a little harsh seeing as they are the Clan Owner, maybe demote to something like deputy leader instead?
Also, how will the automated system pick the new Leader?
The first Co-Owner should be promoted by seniority.
Esploratore said :
No support for an automated system to remove inactive clan leaders. The time to develop this would be better used in other clan-related areas.
Clans take so much work to build up and the thought of some automated system determining a clan's fate just doesn't seem right.
If JaGex can't work with the clans that have an inactive owner on an ad hoc basis, they shouldn't intervene at all, imo. I fully agree with this sentiment however. Instead of demoting or removing anyone though, just putting the original owner(s) on the fly (a list of "senior owners"
would suffice. When one returned, they would be able to be instantly re-instated. Depending how "high up", all the way to the original Owner, would be able to resume command over somebody added to the "senior" list based on tenure of the Co-Owner, then Deputy Owner spots. If there are NO players remaining in either of those lists, the clan should be considered disbanded, and removed from the game.
That's the best scenario I can come up with right now. It's fair, if you feel you MUST have a system. I don't think it's anyone's place however to do this. I just think there needs to be a BETTER idea conceived to remove inactive clans. Clan:
l||l°~
Void Nation
~°l||l
|
20+ Veteran
|
Balance is Eternal
JAGeX Verified Clan Site:
voidnation.boards.n3t
03-Dec-2013 19:17:49
Quick find code: 86-87-286-65225376 Back to Top