Forums

¥ Yrolg's Reviews ¥

Quick find code: 49-50-196-58521317

Logan Shafts
Dec Member 2023

Logan Shafts

Posts: 3,211 Adamant Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
Well, I would say a little of both then.
Personally if I were reviewing a thread designed like my own is, I would probably examine the stories first and then try to give advice to the author about two major things: The qualities of the stories themselves, and the properties of his or her writing style and ability.
But it would be a bit hard, I must admit, to produce a balanced review on a thread which is made in that manner. I hope this isn't such a problem that it makes you want to make a rule about anthologies being denied, haha.

15-Jul-2010 17:54:06

Yrolg

Yrolg

Posts: 25,296 Sapphire Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
I wouldn't ever disqualify anthologies. They can be both my favourite form of reading as well as the only medium many users can consistently create. I will either find a way to incorporate them into the existing thread's layout or will reconstruct the thread so that it accommodates their style.

15-Jul-2010 17:57:30

Chuk

Chuk

Posts: 14,177 Opal Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
If I may interject, I have a suggestion as to how I've reviewed anthologies in the past:
For the numerical piece, I judged the average of all the stories, but then in the written portion, I picked one or two positives and one or two negatives for each individual story (about a paragraph of writing) and then chose a couple stories to go into more depth on, usually the one I thought was best and the one I thought was worst.
I don't know what you all think of that, but I thought I'd throw it out there.

15-Jul-2010 20:51:34

Logan Shafts
Dec Member 2023

Logan Shafts

Posts: 3,211 Adamant Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
Yrolg:
I'm relieved to hear you say that. Though I have written quite a few longer peices, none of them were ever of the quality that my shorter stories have had, mainly due to the fact that it is easier to edit a short story.
Chuk:
I happen to like that idea. You have gone over my stories in the past and have always been helpful, so employing your method may be a good idea. ^^

15-Jul-2010 23:11:42

[#F3XG0LQ4O]

[#F3XG0LQ4O]

Posts: 3,400 Adamant Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
Logan, I have to agree to you on that. My short stories that I have written in my spare time are of much higher standard and quality than my longer ones due to the exact same reason as you. However, I am beginning to prefer longer, more extensive chronicles purely for the fact that they allow one to develop the plot more thoroughly and intricately which I enjoy doing.

20-Jul-2010 19:36:23

Looksavebee

Looksavebee

Posts: 334 Silver Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
On the subject of short vs long stories, I must say that I've always enjoyed seeing shorts that are written well. In my opinion, a well written short is harder to do than a well written long story for one simple fact - length.
In a short story the amount of words available to you requires you to pick and choose carefully, as a wrong choice can make other critical aspects of a story that much harder to convey concisely. To get a well developed plot across in three posts is harder than in 30. To develop your characters in those same three posts is even harder, then to have a good amount of description is even harder again. To get the same across in a full length story requires more dedication, yes, but not necessarily more skill. Not that I'm saying you need not be skilled to write a full length story. All I'm over is the misconception of shorts being the easy way out. Often it is the harder choice, if you're doing it right.
P.S: Just making this clear. I'm not saying shorts are better than full length, nor am I saying full length stories require no skill. Both require a certain skill set that the other does not necessarily require.

20-Jul-2010 19:46:39

Yrolg

Yrolg

Posts: 25,296 Sapphire Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
Logan Shafts,
Hello. Unfortunately extenuating circumstances have forced me to delay the projected completion date of your review until Tuesday, August 17th. This is, I most regretfully state, the earliest possible completion date, and further delays should not be far from expectation.

27-Jul-2010 18:23:57

Yrolg

Yrolg

Posts: 25,296 Sapphire Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
I am not biased towards short or long stories: though I must say that my preferred creation is on the shorter side (between 100-5000 words).
Both sets require their own unique skills and pose different challenges with the writer. In short stories, it is how to fit sufficient information in so that the reader can comprehend what is going on; in long stories, it is how to limit your information so that the reader can comprehend what is going on without be lost in a sea of unnecessary details. Long stories and short stories alike can be enjoyed, and both have their successes and failures.
I like to think that many prefer the shorter stories because they can more easily be read in a single sitting an are oftentimes simpler. I know that being able to knock out the entire piece at once is very helpful to its reception and that I like simplicity. Simplicity is, afterall, the greatest form of sophistication.

27-Jul-2010 18:27:40

Logan Shafts
Dec Member 2023

Logan Shafts

Posts: 3,211 Adamant Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
Yrolg:
Delays were expected. Don't worry about it, I barely have time to get on and check these forums anymore myself - so I appreciate the effort that you put into reviews, even if they take a while to produce. =]
In response to the discussion regarding long versus short stories, here are a few quotes by famous people that I believe represent my position adequately.
"To get the right word in the right place is a rare achievement. To condense the diffused light of a page of thought into the luminous flash of a single sentence, is worthy to rank as a prize composition just by itself...Anybody can have ideas--the difficulty is to express them without squandering a quire of paper on an idea that ought to be reduced to one glittering paragraph."
> Mark Twain
"Good things, when short, are twice as good."
> Gracián

28-Jul-2010 16:32:09

Quick find code: 49-50-196-58521317 Back to Top