Forums
Artisan revisited
Quick find code: 380-381-33-65435511
Original message details are unavailable.
Original message details are unavailable.
As it is, I'll be voting no and here's why:
-Artisan doesn't have a strong reason to exist. It's not really a true skill on its own; you're not becoming a better artisan, you're becoming a better smith or runecrafter while also arbitrarily getting XP in an Artisan skill.
-This ties into the above, but what I'm seeing is a list of additions to existing skills. I don't really see a point to adding Artisan as a requirement to craft or smith something.
I do not like this idea for a skill at all. It just doesn't seem fun or satisfying in any way. I don't feel like going in depth on a response as to why I don't like it because there is just too much I dislike about the entire thing. I don't think OSRS really needs a new skill at the moment and if the new skill isn't something special I don't think this game ever needs one. The entire shortlist was awful in my opinion.
This skill just seems like it would be annoying to train and have in the game. I don't want to be pulled away from traditional training methods I enjoy and appreciate to have to give time to Artisan. I don't want for the rest of my RS days to see this bad skill on my skill tab or hear players talk about it.
This idea is really sub-par. If a new skill comes out it should be amazing and make you feel a sense of excitement and wonder at the game again. This just feels like a chore. There is nothing magical about it.
I will be voting no on a new skill until one which deserves to be in the game is offered.
Erm... what the hell do you think slayer is? slayer is just leveling combat through that skill, Artisan is basically slayer but for skills besides combat. I DO however agree that its not "amazing" or very exciting, i will vote yes pn Artisan, but i'd honestly prefer Sailing even though it will never happen
Original message details are unavailable.
As it is, I'll be voting no and here's why:
-Artisan doesn't have a strong reason to exist. It's not really a true skill on its own; you're not becoming a better artisan, you're becoming a better smith or runecrafter while also arbitrarily getting XP in an Artisan skill.
-This ties into the above, but what I'm seeing is a list of additions to existing skills. I don't really see a point to adding Artisan as a requirement to craft or smith something.
I do not like this idea for a skill at all. It just doesn't seem fun or satisfying in any way. I don't feel like going in depth on a response as to why I don't like it because there is just too much I dislike about the entire thing. I don't think OSRS really needs a new skill at the moment and if the new skill isn't something special I don't think this game ever needs one. The entire shortlist was awful in my opinion.
This skill just seems like it would be annoying to train and have in the game. I don't want to be pulled away from traditional training methods I enjoy and appreciate to have to give time to Artisan. I don't want for the rest of my RS days to see this bad skill on my skill tab or hear players talk about it.
This idea is really sub-par. If a new skill comes out it should be amazing and make you feel a sense of excitement and wonder at the game again. This just feels like a chore. There is nothing magical about it.
I will be voting no on a new skill until one which deserves to be in the game is offered.
-Diane Meyer
Erm... what the hell do you think slayer is? slayer is just leveling combat through that skill, Artisan is basically slayer but for skills besides combat. I DO however agree that its not "amazing" or very exciting, i will vote yes pn Artisan, but i'd honestly prefer Sailing even though it will never happen
20-Jun-2014 23:08:30
okay so i didn't really like the initial idea but this one seems a little better. so i would suggest a few things. first of all no there should be no massive combat boost related to this skill at all... I'm gonna agree others that i don't wanna take a step towards rs3. so i think it should be purely skill based. now as for reward.
unlimited amounts of styles that we can create for clothes. because if rs players like one thing its standing out and looking nice. so the ability to add on to our skill cape without removing the basic symbol of the skill, being able to create a shield that has the skill symbol on it etc.. so pretty much the ability to design more extravagant outfits for ourselves non tradable of course! and of course these will be opened up with the higher levels your gain in the respective skills, fletching, smithing, crafting, rc. now it would be nice that once your create a style, no one else can create that style unless they by the style off of you. that way opening up another source of income for those with imaginations and not allowing others just to simply feast off of others idea at no cost.....
feedback please! oh btw these clothes armor and weapons made will all have 0 combat stats... but also it would be nice that if you could customize armor that you have so it would like smart talks 3rd age mage top.... something like that
just another thought....~
unlimited amounts of styles that we can create for clothes. because if rs players like one thing its standing out and looking nice. so the ability to add on to our skill cape without removing the basic symbol of the skill, being able to create a shield that has the skill symbol on it etc.. so pretty much the ability to design more extravagant outfits for ourselves non tradable of course! and of course these will be opened up with the higher levels your gain in the respective skills, fletching, smithing, crafting, rc. now it would be nice that once your create a style, no one else can create that style unless they by the style off of you. that way opening up another source of income for those with imaginations and not allowing others just to simply feast off of others idea at no cost.....
feedback please! oh btw these clothes armor and weapons made will all have 0 combat stats... but also it would be nice that if you could customize armor that you have so it would like smart talks 3rd age mage top.... something like that
just another thought....~
20-Jun-2014 23:27:46
Quick find code: 380-381-33-65435511 Back to Top