Not looking forward to it... Like a lot of people already said: it sounds much more like a minigame.
I agree with the adventure/exploring side, but not being brought by a totally new skill. Since it would imply several existing skills for its completition (smith, cons, craft like you said and some more IMO), it shouldn't be a skill by itself, but more a minigame.
I also agree with the fact that a **MINIGAME** based on the dungeoneering skill (excluding the overpowered gear rewards) already receives MUCH MORE positive feedback from the community.
Other things I've read in the community's answers that I agree with
-sounds way too repetitive
-always been treated as a joke (in a negative way, so why would it even be thought of?)
I have read quite a few times that Lady Lumbridge would do a good first boat..
Wow I really hope that you will not do this huge hit to the small, but important amount of pures that actually like skilling/completition too.. If it passes with my 'no' I really hope it will be available for pures too. Would be another hit in the face to those who decided not to level their defence, but do other things along with PKing..
11-Aug-2015 17:59:48