Forums

(feedback about) General Thread is locked

Quick find code: 278-279-614-66169608

2_Tron

2_Tron

Posts: 22,959 Opal Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
Wilf said :
I used to care about threads being left in general to the detriment of the other sections but it was a waste of time, for instance

I recall a few years ago a thread about grammar on the forums that was posted there by a former fmod and which within about 2 hours had had 10 different fmods post on it some of whom hadn't posted for 6month +

Now being a regular of the Off Topic section I thought that might be a nice thread for the off topic section a thread about how we are influenced by a posts grammar because grammar on the forums isn't really about the game of runescape is it I would have been happy for it to be moved here either.


Ultimately I was told by one fmod that the thread had been deemed an exception to the rules another said they couldn't do anything due to the other mods posting and I eventually received an inbox message from Mod Balance then head of CM issuing me with me a cease and desist regarding me posting about the thread. It didn't work in actuality all it did was reinforce my view that they just don't care or even read reports fully as in the message he referred to the thread as being mine and that it had been correctly moved to the right section.

So ye all these years and still no change perhaps as Arch said if Mod Kari is more proactive than the previous cm mods then we might get to see something happen, but more than likely she'll move on to pastures new before anything happens and we return to the status quo.




In reality I posted about it for sheer devilment :D and I also care very much so not that I really go into the place
Thanks Wilf, as this is a perfect example of a thread's topic that doesn't have a specific home at all and could be placed anywhere in The RSOF.
Grammar is about our communication skills and that includes all communications in many directions and forms.

08-Jul-2020 20:27:18

2_Tron

2_Tron

Posts: 22,959 Opal Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
Wilf said :
Oh an another thing that bothered me was that the general section is also a place where you can discuss jagex.

Yet threads would be locked for not discussing runescape or moved to Off Topic
You can discuss Jagex here in
Websites & Forums
as long as it is about
Websites & Forums
related topics involving Jagex ... and most likely you will get an answer of a true JMod or more than 1.

08-Jul-2020 20:29:57

2_Tron

2_Tron

Posts: 22,959 Opal Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
Southeaster said :
If someone keeps misplacing threads in General despite numerous warnings by the Fmods, then they need to be given a forum mute.
Would you agree with me when I say a "players profile" determines the need of handing out a forum mute rather than "numerous warnings by the FMods"?
A player with 10K of posts and more, with a lot of recent posting, deserves to be muted for purposely misplacing threads and disregarding a forum strap-line and - specific rules.

08-Jul-2020 20:42:19

2_Tron

2_Tron

Posts: 22,959 Opal Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
Loki said :
2_Tron said :
Loki said :
I assume this is because of people posting threads in General knowing that it's the incorrect section, just to get more views over one of the more dead subforums, or am I understanding this incorrectly?
Good point Loki but I can prove all those players thinking the way you did as being wrong.

I have been here in
Websites & Forums
when it still was
Website Forums
and
Forum Feedback Forums
, where players of other forums said this was the most dead forum of The RSOF, being a graveyard where you wouldn't get an answer in a million years.

This
Websites & Forums
forum is almost as occupied as
General
at some moments but it all comes down to how it is Moderated and how well players prepare their threads/content that makes it worth posting in.
To be honest, Website & Forums is the only forum that actually gets JMod responses (from the Web Team) haha! :P
True, very true ... lol. Still makes me laugh when they told us it sometimes looks like a wasps nest in here, in some threads. :P

08-Jul-2020 20:52:15

Southeaster
Nov Member 2014

Southeaster

Posts: 15,318 Opal Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
2_Tron said :
Southeaster said :
If someone keeps misplacing threads in General despite numerous warnings by the Fmods, then they need to be given a forum mute.
Would you agree with me when I say a "players profile" determines the need of handing out a forum mute rather than "numerous warnings by the FMods"?
A player with 10K of posts and more, with a lot of recent posting, deserves to be muted for purposely misplacing threads and disregarding a forum strap-line and - specific rules.
Yes I would agree with you.
Runescape Forumers Discord Server

09-Jul-2020 13:54:50

Maynne

Maynne

Forum Moderator Posts: 52,416 Emerald Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
If someone misplaced a thread in General or whatever forum section, my only reaction is to move it to a subforum that best fit its context if I ever see it - if no other team mate or superiors acted on the thread.

I personally do not recall any instance when I applied a harsh penalty against a forumer for such action, it is a minor misdemeanor at its worst and an honest mistake on the part of the forumer at best. Your thread will be moved, and that's about it - that's the extent of my judgement call.

If we rank all possible rule violations that a person can do in this board, misplaced threads is at the bottom of the pile. Some may find it annoying to look at a handful of misplaced threads here and there - but it barely cause any serious damage for this board.

09-Jul-2020 14:16:57

Mrs Ana

Mrs Ana

Posts: 8,998 Rune Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
I do not believe this is a serious problem. If a thread is misplaced, it may be moved by an F-Mod that is available at the time. Throughout my tenure here, I have never seen anyone get punished or banned for misplacing a thread. Granted, once you misplace a thread and it's moved, most of the time the person involved learns the lesson and the mistake is not committed again. Yes, it may be annoying to some, but I am sure that the F-Mod are willing to move the thread if and when necessary.

Personally, I disagree with punishing anyone for misplacing a thread. Now, if it's done blatantly and on purpose, then that's another story; however, I have yet to see something like this. As of right now, this issue is nonexistent.

09-Jul-2020 16:40:13 - Last edited on 09-Jul-2020 16:40:35 by Mrs Ana

Tranq
Nov
fmod Member
2007

Tranq

Forum Moderator Posts: 61,815 Emerald Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
There is something to the "viewership ideology" general typically goes see far more foot traffic than the other subforums these days.

Here's an issue with moving the thread though even if there is a better place it belongs. The damage is already done from a thread standpoint it exists pushing a thread into chewie's open mouth. We can't reverse that at least at the f-mod level.

Now we move it an index thread still remains that links to the new locale. So now we've pushed yet another thread into chewie's mouth. The original misplaced one and the shifted properly placed one.

So I take them on a thread by thread basis. If it's a one and done answer, I see no point in moving it away from general as it will die out on it's own. If it's got substance and certainly belongs elsewhere, then yes it gets shunted off to it's proper home. However that's just my thoughts on the matter.
When the day becomes the night and the sky becomes the sea, when the clock strikes heavy and there’s no time for tea; and in our darkest hour, before my final rhyme, she will come back home to Wonderland and turn back the hands of time.

10-Jul-2020 03:00:46

Mrs Ana

Mrs Ana

Posts: 8,998 Rune Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
Tranq said :
Here's an issue with moving the thread though even if there is a better place it belongs. The damage is already done from a thread standpoint it exists pushing a thread into chewie's open mouth. We can't reverse that at least at the f-mod level.
Hey, Tranq. I agree with your points. I do want to share that if a thread is already in page 50th and is about to disappear, I am sure that it has already served its purpose. I know that it is still considered a "lost" thread due to the fact that a new one has been created, but if a thread is about to be devoured by Chewie, I am sure it's for a good reason. A grave-bumped thread is something that we do not want, anyway. And, if that specific thread were relevant, we can all agree that it wouldn't be about to fall off ;) .

10-Jul-2020 17:20:39

Quick find code: 278-279-614-66169608 Back to Top