Okay Blue, here you go.
As a whole, your work is not bad. However, I don't find it particularly engaging or interesting either, and much of the bio is wasted on the repetition of facts that have already been stated, such as Treznor's fear and specific reactions to those things that he is fearful
of
. You have a start on the kind of specificity that I am looking for, but fall far short. And while you attempt in some ways to tell a story with the character regarding his heritage as the Captain of the Guard's son, it's not nearly as fleshed out as it could be, and indeed there's only one moment when you draw attention to it.
The main thing about your assignment that irks me is you seem to be right on the cusp of providing a wealth of detail, but then hang back and give only generalizations. You keep mentioning his apprenticeship to one of the palace cooks, but not why he enjoyed it, or what he did apart from train. You mention his not wanting to be a guard and fear of combat, but not the origins of these wants and emotions. His life is painted in broad strokes, and as such he could be one of many, many different individuals, with little except for the company he keeps to mark him out. Where are the little idiosyncracies, where the deeper quirks, the deeper motivations? Get into his head, root out the experiences that have affected him. Sketch, but with small, intricate details instead of big lines. It can be rough and disjointed, but in order to make up for that you have to have
more
.
On another note, much of Treznor's character is made up of accepted clichés: his life as an orphan of mysterious background, his love of books and cooking rather than the fighting which he is forced into, etc. This has been done… well, a lot. If you watch or have read Game of Thrones, think of Sam Tarly.
18-Jun-2013 21:31:23
- Last edited on
18-Jun-2013 21:32:39
by
Xereva