Forums

¥ Yrolg's Reviews ¥

Quick find code: 49-50-196-58521317

Areno3

Areno3

Posts: 12,906 Opal Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
Lol, I kind of forgot about this thread. But yes, Yrolg, it is fine with me if you review both stories. Do you have an estimation when you will be finished in doing that? I'm not trying to hurry you; I have all the time in the world. Trust me. ;)

28-Jul-2012 12:55:03 - Last edited on 28-Jul-2012 12:55:24 by Areno3

Yrolg

Yrolg

Posts: 25,296 Sapphire Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
When Breathing Stops, by Emperor Worf
A feedback-based review by Yrolg

Overall, the tone of the piece is well-established and the story you tell is compelling. There are certain areas that could use improvement, however, and some misspellings in the story. I want to be clear that a careful proofreading and stylistic edit of the piece could produce a magnificent short story, as the ideas that inspired the piece — and resonate within the reader after he finishes it — are poignant. It has potential.

The most striking aspect of the piece is not the melancholy atmosphere or the actual plot; it, instead, is what I can only describe as overzealous physical description that detracts from the flow of many sentences and distracts the reader from each clause's point by miring him in unnecessary detail. The beauty of a short story emanates from its simplicity and concisity. A piece of this length has strength in its ability to transport the reader on a sojourn to a familiar place that bears no explanation. The expectation for holistic description and pedantic detail that bog down novels does not apply, so the twice- and thrice-described objects of When Breathing Stops seems very anachronistic in style.

A few examples of this pop out in just the first sentence: "The sounds of slow, labored breathing and soft sobbing wafted from the shadows of the hospital room." The important points of this sentence is that breathing is difficult — ie health is poor — for the father and the daughter is sad. Those points can be communicated to the reader in a way that is not as clunky and forced, a benefit of which is the reader will be able to distinguish the points more quickly and clearly. This also adds an opportunity to use authorial flair in the introduction to make it compelling emotionally but also stylistically intriguing.

21-Sep-2013 15:42:52

Yrolg

Yrolg

Posts: 25,296 Sapphire Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
"Soft sobs pierced the ever-extending silence between the labored breaths of the hospital bed in a shadowed room."

This adds an excitement to the first sentence — through the word pierce, which is a very active verb in connotation (like piercing someone's armor) — and illustrates just how lonely the daughter must be, that the only things in the world to her are the sadness she feels and the ever-growing silences between breaths. It also serves to emphasize the laborious breathing and helps to foreshadow the end of the piece. Finally, by attributing this breathing to the hospital bed, we are emphasizing the physicality of the breathing, stressing its importance to the patient's presence in the physical world. This juxtaposes well with the idea that at the end (or middle) of the piece, this patient in fact dies, moving on from the physical world.

The end of the first example, however, shows an even simpler solution: "Out in the hallway, someone flipped a light on, and the beams spilled through the small rectangular window of the door to reveal a young woman sitting hunched over a weary-looking aged man." The sentence describes too much in too much detail; it often uses two or three words where just one would do. Please also note that throughout the piece, commas are missing from double-described words. When two adjectives describe the same noun, the should normally be separated by a comma (ie the small, rectangular window).

"Out in the hallway, a light flickered on, and the beams spilled through the small window of the door to reveal a young woman hunched over a weary-looking man."

There are other ways to make the sentence stronger, but I think you can get the gist of my point from the changes.

21-Sep-2013 15:43:05

Quick find code: 49-50-196-58521317 Back to Top