Personally, from feedback in the comments and actual experience from back in the day, I think craters should be off the table. The only way you'd be able to introduce craters in a way they could pass would be to efficiently find a way to eliminate clans camping the entrances, and even then there just seem to be too many issues spread across the board that players have with craters. Put simply, I don't think it would ever pass.
That being said I don't think a BH world would pass either. As much as I would enjoy a BH mechanic to be invoked at some point, in a PVP world it really would split up the community, even a tiny bit more. That in itself is a reason to vote no, seeing how thin-spread PKers already are as of late.
My personal opinion is along the lines of a few others I've seen in the comments and would revolve around eliminating the PVP worlds and introducing the mechanic back into the wilderness on some worlds. No, not a designated mini game area, the whole wilderness, but only on a few worlds. Then those who wish to participate in BH have a place to do it, while those who enjoy just regular PKing have their worlds as well. As for the exact mechanics and specific rules, you'll have to find inspiration elsewhere. But this, if the vast majority voted for it, would push the PKing community back together a little, and make it seem a bit more lively in the wilderness again.
10-Jul-2014 00:10:48