Looking pretty good, but was surprised by 2 things:
1. That the first Question was lumped rather than semi-broken down, but I guess you're probably right that most of those would pass anyways. However, maybe consider breaking it up a little bit?
2. New Staff Slayer Drop! Was very excited to see this being polled, however I'd have to agree with others that it seems to fall just short of that good mark (which probably came from the discussion involving people being against a staff that was so powerful and cheap as the polypore but wanting something like it).
~Feedback towards the New Staff~
- Cost: I think you guys got this part perfect, only suggestions here would be trying to include slightly different underused runes such as Body/Soul, but I can see how those might not 'fit' a combat spell.
- Attack Speed: I'd have to agree with bringing it up a notch to 2.4s Speed.
- Level 75 Max Damage(17): Feels like a good number if it has the boosted speed, if the speed remains the same then this number should go up a few points to 18/19.
- Level 99 Max Damage(22): This falls short of the money to me, with its current attack speed id expect a max around 34/35. If you were to boost its attack speed id expect a max around 27-30.
Finally, 3 questions over it if yous guys have a moment:
1. You stated: "Stat-boosts and stat-reduction effects would modify the max hit". Does this include prayer boosted stats or is it only including Visible Stat Changes?
2. You said it wouldn't work in PvP, what happens if you killing an NPC with it in the wild and a Pker attacks you? Would you be defenseless or will you get to retaliate with it?
3. What model is going to be used? Though it probably can't be done yet, wielding a Kraken Tenticle would be epic (Tenticle could be a Recoloured whip)
I'll probably comeback with more thoughts later :/
Thank you for your time and hard work OSRS Team!
~Afropunk~
1. That the first Question was lumped rather than semi-broken down, but I guess you're probably right that most of those would pass anyways. However, maybe consider breaking it up a little bit?
2. New Staff Slayer Drop! Was very excited to see this being polled, however I'd have to agree with others that it seems to fall just short of that good mark (which probably came from the discussion involving people being against a staff that was so powerful and cheap as the polypore but wanting something like it).
~Feedback towards the New Staff~
- Cost: I think you guys got this part perfect, only suggestions here would be trying to include slightly different underused runes such as Body/Soul, but I can see how those might not 'fit' a combat spell.
- Attack Speed: I'd have to agree with bringing it up a notch to 2.4s Speed.
- Level 75 Max Damage(17): Feels like a good number if it has the boosted speed, if the speed remains the same then this number should go up a few points to 18/19.
- Level 99 Max Damage(22): This falls short of the money to me, with its current attack speed id expect a max around 34/35. If you were to boost its attack speed id expect a max around 27-30.
Finally, 3 questions over it if yous guys have a moment:
1. You stated: "Stat-boosts and stat-reduction effects would modify the max hit". Does this include prayer boosted stats or is it only including Visible Stat Changes?
2. You said it wouldn't work in PvP, what happens if you killing an NPC with it in the wild and a Pker attacks you? Would you be defenseless or will you get to retaliate with it?
3. What model is going to be used? Though it probably can't be done yet, wielding a Kraken Tenticle would be epic (Tenticle could be a Recoloured whip)
I'll probably comeback with more thoughts later :/
Thank you for your time and hard work OSRS Team!
~Afropunk~
17-Jan-2014 20:28:12
