Also, to address some earlier posts:
Kitty: Sorry for the delay. Would I be right in saying that your counter-argument is that the land was referred to as Hallowvale during the 2nd Age and therefore had to be under Efaritay's control then? That sounds right, but there are a few things that need sorting out before we can settle on this conclusion.
1. What age does Zemouregal's memory come from? If it comes from the Third Age, it adds credence to the old idea that the Queen Efaritay was in charge of Morytania during the Second Age, though it isn't a guarantee that this was the case. Why not? Zemouregal could simply be using modern names to describe the past. Athrenn points out this possibility in another scenario. Bear in mind that the account must have been written
after
the Second Age, since the end of his memory talks about the God Wars beginning in earnest only at the end of the account.
As far as I'm aware, we do not know when Zemouregal's memory was created, but please correct me if I'm wrong.
2. Jagex has made a lot of lore mistakes and contradictions recently. It is possible that the mod who wrote the memories made a mistake in referring to 2nd Age Morytania and Hallowvale. For example, Hallowvale was just the city now known as Meiyerditch, but
Hallowland
was the region of Morytania today. Yet the account says ' Drakan was promised the whole region of Hallowvale.' A minor mistake, perhaps, but one worth considering.
The other possibility is that the contradiction was deliberate. So far we've been very much kept in the dark as to the general history of Morytania, so it could have been a conscious decision on Jagex' part keep us guessing by calling it 'the region of Hallowvale'.
Either way, I'm sure we can all agree that Jagex needs to give us answers about Morytania soon before more confusion arises.
19-Apr-2014 15:43:49