Yo. I'm posting some random thoughts here, just while they're still fresh.
Just finished the Light Within. It's sort of odd, it feels like two different quests - one fairly okay quest for the first half, a fantastic, adventurous, thought-provoking quest with very high production values in the second half, and then back to mere adequacy at the very end. The scope, tone, depth, and maturity of the narrative undergo a couple of very drastic, sudden shifts, which makes it hard for me to make an overall assessment on this.
That said, it's much better than I expected (even with my opposition to Seren's return). Far larger than I expected, too. This feels even bigger than Plague's End, and used so many new assets, when all I expected was a small-medium gofer type quest, what with all the effort that had to go into the rewards. I thought the graphics department did a particularly excellent job - I liked the strangeness of the crystal root hollow, I loved the well chamber, with the watery reflections, the ground water flowing away in adjacent pockets, the prize framed by intricate lattice sconces - brilliant.
And then Tarddiad! I remember feeling so let down when we finally entered Freneskae to find some disconnected, rocky agility course after Mod Mark had built it up so much. But on Tarddiad, it really felt like we were seeing a piece of a unique, completely alien landscape. The design of the rocks, with their odd swirled cleavage, the crystal flora, the shifting lights and odd mists, the ruins of simple wooden structures with grand foundations of stone and crystal - it all suggested a plane with its own ecology, its own morphology, with a biosphere that's evolved on its own, and given rise to a distinct culture. I was especially impressed they were able to create something so consistent with the many, at times conflicting, accounts of Tarddiad we've had over the years. It had its alien beauty, but infused with melancholy, clearly lesser than 'perfect' Gielinor.
28-Aug-2015 02:25:21
- Last edited on
28-Aug-2015 03:13:30
by
Rondstat