Forums
‡ The best quest ever? Vote! ‡
Quick find code: 341-342-196-65106546
Robo Hobo
said
:
Hmm...Difficult.
I'm gonna say Do No Evil for now, since I loved the story progression in it, the puzzles and combat were fun, it took me about 6 hours, the music was nice, and of course, we learned a good amount of lore.
Perhaps this will change when I start and complete my redoing all quests spree
Yeah, it did change after finishing the marathon. I forgot to post here right after, I know I have a top 10 list that I wrote right as completing it though, I think that would be more accurate than what I think now since back then it was super all fresh in my memory.
But, in the end, While Guthix Sleeps is indeed my favorite quest. Not an uncommon favorite for people, but after having done it twice, and all other quests for that matter I really was able to compare it without any outside bias, and it was indeed the best one for me. A lot of elements were well done, the adventure of going all over the world, there were very little amounts of things I could criticize about it. (One being that random part where you knock over the truth serum and have to make another seeming rather needless)
Also the irony will never leave me about the fact that the best quest of many is the worst in the perspective of the adventurer. Losing the Stone of Jas to Lucien, a lot of your friends from earlier adventurers, with only an alliance (that later on mostly die too) to speak of as a success from it all.
But then I always think, perhaps that's a part of what makes it so special. You can only fully appreciate a story when you experience it through the eyes of one of its characters.
Hmm...Difficult.
I'm gonna say Do No Evil for now, since I loved the story progression in it, the puzzles and combat were fun, it took me about 6 hours, the music was nice, and of course, we learned a good amount of lore.
Perhaps this will change when I start and complete my redoing all quests spree
Yeah, it did change after finishing the marathon. I forgot to post here right after, I know I have a top 10 list that I wrote right as completing it though, I think that would be more accurate than what I think now since back then it was super all fresh in my memory.
But, in the end, While Guthix Sleeps is indeed my favorite quest. Not an uncommon favorite for people, but after having done it twice, and all other quests for that matter I really was able to compare it without any outside bias, and it was indeed the best one for me. A lot of elements were well done, the adventure of going all over the world, there were very little amounts of things I could criticize about it. (One being that random part where you knock over the truth serum and have to make another seeming rather needless)
Also the irony will never leave me about the fact that the best quest of many is the worst in the perspective of the adventurer. Losing the Stone of Jas to Lucien, a lot of your friends from earlier adventurers, with only an alliance (that later on mostly die too) to speak of as a success from it all.
But then I always think, perhaps that's a part of what makes it so special. You can only fully appreciate a story when you experience it through the eyes of one of its characters.
16-Jun-2014 23:17:07
Robo Hobo
said
:
Hah, that is a brilliant quote. OSF, BTMR, Returning Clarence, ACS and MABA also had me laugh out quite loudly.
Anyway, I've changed your vote. Would you perhaps care to share your top 10? I'm quite interested which quests are in it, and I'd like to compare it to my own. :3 Bizarre Boron Fusswell, scryer extraordinaire. OSRS: POH ideas & RS3 minigames & achievement ideas !
Player:
So… Call yourself a navigator huh? Way to plot a course that’s a big circle!
"Bird's-Eye" Jack:
Frankly sirrah your rudeness is quite appalling! My calculations and plotted course were expertly calculated, and there can be only one reason why the ship has failed to arrive at its expected destination.
Player:
Oh really? What’s that then? Wrong kind of waves? Your steering wheel got stuck?
"Bird's-Eye" Jack:
I do not have to take this kind of abuse from a common stowaway.
Player:
I’ll have you know that I am a personal friend of the Captain, and he himself invited me aboard for a small cruise around Lunar Isle along with a variety of local delicacies and beverages!
"Bird's-Eye" Jack:
Really? You don’t seem like the type he would make friends with.
Player:
Oh, absolutely. Me and him go way back. Waaaaaay back. We’re like… apples and custard. Everybody says so. Yup, me and Captain Renney, we’re a team.
"Bird's-Eye" Jack:
You mean Captain Bent**y?
Player:
Right. Bent**y. That*s what I said.
"Bird's-Eye" Jack:
No you did*’t. You called him Captain Renney.
Player:
Oh, yeah, it’s like a nickname. Only his friends are allowed to call him that.
"Bird's-Eye" Jack:
Yet I have known him for over 20 years and he has never asked to be referred to as anything except Captain Bent**y.
Player:
Wow, he must hate you.
Hah, that is a brilliant quote. OSF, BTMR, Returning Clarence, ACS and MABA also had me laugh out quite loudly.
Anyway, I've changed your vote. Would you perhaps care to share your top 10? I'm quite interested which quests are in it, and I'd like to compare it to my own. :3 Bizarre Boron Fusswell, scryer extraordinaire. OSRS: POH ideas & RS3 minigames & achievement ideas !
Perhaps you're half right; perhaps we can't win. But we can fight.
— Zanik
18-Jun-2014 09:31:07
Quick find code: 341-342-196-65106546 Back to Top