Second point - a little bit of a conflicting description for trialers and ranked keyers.
"The goal for this rank [Trialer] is to have a group of leaders who help the group as a whole improve, exactly like the new keyer rank."
"If the [ranked] keyer feels that any part of a new member's performance in a trial floor is not of sufficient quality, the keyer must not pass the trial floor.
...
While new members who have failed a trial floor can simply re-take it, trial floors are never to be passed just because someone still needs one or because it feels harsh to fail them more than once."
KABDE is a lot different than typical rush style dungeoneering, and I think most of us know that. Its great to have trialers who are willing to be able to teach those new to the group the important tactics of the style so that they are able to improve. After all, all of us didn't learn how to dungeoneer or do KABDE overnight (ok, well, maybe some have, but not all).
The concerning bit here is the part where it basically says that if a ranked keyer is not necessarily impressed with the work of the new trial, that the player is to not pass the trial, and (maybe I'm interpreting this wrong), be removed from the group as trial floors are not meant to be re-taken. As I said, not everyone can learn everything right away, and while they may do their four trial floors, they may need a little bit more time to pick up on this. I would personally hate to see a new person to the clan end up starting their first trial floor, ending up with a ranked keyer, having a small bit of trouble with picking something up that is different with the style, and not be accepted further into the group.
At the same time of course, I don't know how easy (or hard) the ranked keyers are planning to be on new trials, but its a concern that I felt might be best to be discussed as while we all want the members of the group to be good at the style, people do need time to learn the style itself.
02-Dec-2012 03:55:18