forums.rs

Forums

Member cap

Quick find code: 86-87-841-65717057

of 6
Chunksofplum
Jan Member 2010

Chunksofplum

Posts: 141 Iron Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
Salcos said :
Tribelewits said :
Salcos said :
It still seems to me as if one person owning multiple clans with over 1000 people, is only doing so (whether or not they realize it) to just be a big clan with a lot of people. They aren't really doing it for any benefit other than to have a lot of accounts in a clan they own for the sake of collecting them, and gaining prestige through it. It also gives them a way to get their ideas upvoted on runelabs.

Owner-Hey guys i suggested this on runelabs go approve it
Clan members-Okay!

Really?
I challenge you sir, to find me 1 runelabs idea posted by one of our clan owners, that might suggest that what you are saying there is even remotely close to what you are suggesting there.

Also, I am not making up rules.

By clan owners, you mean the one person who owns all three of your clans?

There are 5 deputies and 1 owner yes, but the deputies and owners all work together as a team and are the same rank

I feel we have really veered from the original topic here and its more of a justify to me why what we are doing inst cheating

they way we run our clan is the way we and 1100 other people enjoy and its not against any rules as Mod Maz explained

i see no harm and no need for the topic to become negative, if you where genuinely interested in how we run the 3 clans i would understand but i feels rather more of a negative light that a curious one

Your original question was is it bending rules which has been answered but you are now and in many post insinuating that multi clan communities are made of "accounts" as you keep saying not members its been explained to you that we have since our clan logger began recruited 5.2k members if we where just "collecting accounts" would we not be at number 11 by now rather than 3?

15-Dec-2015 21:05:10

Chunksofplum
Jan Member 2010

Chunksofplum

Posts: 141 Iron Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
Salcos said :
Also, since you are technically three separate clans but consider yourself one, you should only have two reps, representing all three of your clans.

Tell me why this is the case

We are 3 clans and are entitled to the representation in each clan

To be blunt you are coming off very Green eyed monster here and i don't think the topic is moving along healthy now

ciao

15-Dec-2015 21:08:42

Tribelewits

Tribelewits

Posts: 1,123 Mithril Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
Salcos said :
Tribelewits said :
Salcos said :
It still seems to me as if one person owning multiple clans with over 1000 people, is only doing so (whether or not they realize it) to just be a big clan with a lot of people. They aren't really doing it for any benefit other than to have a lot of accounts in a clan they own for the sake of collecting them, and gaining prestige through it. It also gives them a way to get their ideas upvoted on runelabs.

Owner-Hey guys i suggested this on runelabs go approve it
Clan members-Okay!

Really?
I challenge you sir, to find me 1 runelabs idea posted by one of our clan owners, that might suggest that what you are saying there is even remotely close to what you are suggesting there.

Also, I am not making up rules.

By clan owners, you mean the one person who owns all three of your clans?

Either, you wont find nor the 1 owner of the entire community, nor the co-owners, nor any admin+ who will have had a runelabs idea that you can find which got a big boost thanks to their position.

Salcos said :
Also, since you are technically three separate clans but consider yourself one, you should only have two reps, representing all three of your clans.

You are basically answering yourself here sir. We are technically 3 separate clans.

Since there's no interest whatshowever to figure out how it actually works in our community, but just turned in to ranting and baiting. You'll just have to do with that answer. Proud Co-Owner of the Wolf
Scape
Community
3 P2P Clans, 1 Community
About us

15-Dec-2015 21:33:13

Agita Sage
Dec Member 2007

Agita Sage

Posts: 6,620 Rune Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
Salcos said :
So while going through my index I noticed something and it made me think of the controversy.

So as we all know (and if you don't you are about to) their is a cap of members accounts allowed in clans being 500.

However there are players who own multiple clans (using alts to have ownership) once their clan(s) reach that number of 500. However, isn't this a way just to get around this rule? If this is allowed, what is the point in having a 500 member cap limit? I am not saying that linked clans is wrong, I am just saying that if it is allowed (one person owning multiple clans and treating them as one) then why is there a cap to begin with?

I am eager to hear your debate on the subject.


See the problem is, what you've actually done is guise this thread as the topic above, where what you really meant to say was the following.


Salcos said :
Also, since you are technically three separate clans but consider yourself one, you should only have two reps, representing all three of your clans.


As Plum stated, we're 3 different Clans under the one community structure, each Clan has their own leaders in it running them and each Clan should be allowed their own representatives.

We've never bothered or harmed anyone or any Clan; spite what some other Clan Leaders in this thread may believe.
We've simply kept to ourselves and built up our community over many years and will continue to do so.

If you don't want a multi-Clan system: don't do it; don't involve yourself with it.

For those of us who do, this should be respected and not challenged or attacked, as it has nothing to do with you. Proud Owner of the
Wolf
Scape
Community : 3 Clans, 1 Community

15-Dec-2015 21:43:22

SofaKing

SofaKing

Posts: 1,854 Mithril Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
It was my clans goal to "own a server" with 4, completely full and active clanchats. Can you imagine having like 1000-2000 clannies all on the same world with you?

Some people would hate it. Understandable. Could be to much commotion, spam, etc.
Some would love it.... so much community...

I'm the later, of course.

16-Dec-2015 00:39:56

Mod Matthe

Mod Matthe

Jagex Moderator Forum Profile Posts by user
Each Clan is allowed 2 representatives. Not each community, but each Clan. I have no way of differentiating between Clans which are linked or wholly independent. I also have no way of viewing Clan Alliances for similar purposes. From a CLF management point of view it is a non-existent distinction.

From a Clan Curator point of view we can't see a reason that such relationships between Clans would be banned or even discouraged. Clans are communities and the member cap features for technical reasons rather than because we considered 500 to be the maximum size a Clan could be. Mod MattHe | Former Community Manager, now in Events & occasional Lore Monkey

16-Dec-2015 09:44:35

Chunksofplum
Jan Member 2010

Chunksofplum

Posts: 141 Iron Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
Mod Matthe said :
Each Clan is allowed 2 representatives. Not each community, but each Clan. I have no way of differentiating between Clans which are linked or wholly independent. I also have no way of viewing Clan Alliances for similar purposes. From a CLF management point of view it is a non-existent distinction.

From a Clan Curator point of view we can't see a reason that such relationships between Clans would be banned or even discouraged. Clans are communities and the member cap features for technical reasons rather than because we considered 500 to be the maximum size a Clan could be.

Im glad to read that, i get really passionate about my clan and im directly in charge of the events side, i was starting to feel a little like we where doing something wrong, or at least people felt that way

I feel better now about it

Thanks Plum

16-Dec-2015 11:58:11

Quick find code: 86-87-841-65717057 Back to Top