forums.rs

Forums

Clan XP After Rejoining

Quick find code: 86-87-293-65560185

of 13
MrTibbitz

MrTibbitz

Posts: 3,126 Adamant Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
I'd like an option where clan XP attainment is never lost.
-If you've been a part of a clan, and left for that time, then return later, it's still that clan in which you earned the experience. When you go to the "clanmates" page, you once used to have 'XX experience' listed there, and so it's just holding onto something which was already there.

Clan leader must check an option which either: Disables all members from doing so, or enables all members to do so. The recruit then has the option to accept or reject the offer to return with their old experience, and also have a 7 day reset period after joining.

That's probably a less practical way of doing it and I don't think many individuals would agree. This system could, therefore, be tweaked a little, and I'll give a bit of insight behind the idea:

Currently, I've been busy with real life events for a good few years now. The clan has been up and down a bit, but we're not really open at the moment. I'd like to take the opportunity to branch out and join a new clan, find out what I can do, what I can offer and how the more modern clans operate, as it's been a while since I've really spent time around the clan scene and it's definitely changed over the past few years.

I will then jump back into my current clan (it's currently without operation so there's no issue here) and begin a new leadership adventure once more.

Essentially , it would be a shame to lose a symbol of the dedication I've put into my current clan, considering that I am not giving up on it, but I do want to take the time out to develop a new vision of what I want the clan to be and how I can make it special.


Perhaps players can join a second clan on probation, whilst owners are still aware of their current allegiance to another clan. The issue with this, though, is inter-clan related conflict and unfortunately you can't find a corner of the internet which isn't rife with bad apples.
MrTibbitz
, RIP
AtomicPK FC

21-Feb-2015 22:08:41 - Last edited on 21-Feb-2015 22:12:36 by MrTibbitz

Body btw

Body btw

Posts: 19,488 Opal Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
bump, hey Tibbitz, I've read your post a couple times but haven't been sure how to respond.

I can't really support the idea that clan XP is never lost with a member who leaves the clan. My reason's for wanting to keep clan XP with members who immediately rejoin the clan within 7 days is strictly because of reasons posted in OP. I think once they leave for good, so should their XP. The number's would get to be pretty ridiculous if that were allowed, too :p

In addition to that, I see a problem with people from bigger clan's joining their alt's clan or some smaller clan on a DXPW (for example) and gaining massive amounts of XP and then just leaving. Bad example maybe, but I hope you see my point that this could lead to exploitation. I do not support permanent clan XP for members who leave permanently.

RL Idea:17542
EP: 92-93-568-65222791
"Why are you posting threads, asking questions and making discussion???"


All I do anymore is fish - 2017

26-Feb-2015 09:08:53

E Bom

E Bom

Posts: 740 Steel Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
support ONLY if they rejoin back before the 7 day probation period. That is a fair compromise.

Think about how to figure out how to accommodate for someone who was in clan, left join another clan for month and came back. Their XP would be the same as a month ago?

Look at how confused you will be (and other clan mates) when they come back. It makes it more difficult to also track xp gains if you have a tracker. I just see potential for weird issues that I have yet to foresee.

I definitely support the need for Jagex to look into this. It just has to be before the probation period ends to protect against mass kicks events. Where you have a week to rebuild an accident due to an emotional admin/owner. That is for the good of everyone. It keeps competition fair among high-scores as well.

11-Apr-2015 07:08:59

Quick find code: 86-87-293-65560185 Back to Top