For the description, I don’t know about you, but many reviewers have criticized the lack of it. They’d say that I did*’t devote paragraphs describing Kipplin’s mansion, or RuneScape, or the college, or most things. In terms of actual textural details of each object is not given very much attention. So, on that day at the bench I could have described the colour of the sky, the clouds, the grass, and so on. I’m glad however, that you found it sufficient!
“This entire paragraph almost made me cry. I am currently a “David.” “
Really? In what sense? Many readers told me they least identify with David, and identify with either the narrator or Kipplin. It really is fascinating. Would you mind me asking why you are a ‘David’? Not to mention David is perhaps the most hated character in the story, lol!
“There is one thing that bothered me, and it is a very minor detail. It was during the part where the narrator is in Kipplin’s house. The description is nice, but the demon butler doesn’t seem to be getting enough credit. You mention how nice everything in the house is, and the demon butler kind of seems like a patch of dirt. Yes, it’s there and it could help in some way, but it doesn’t get the significance it deserves.’
--Interesting. When I wrote this I never gave the demon butler much thought, except perhaps it was a hint of a demon in Kipplin, or that a demon butler emphasises how imposing this person is, or simply because it was the best butler available in game. What sort of significance would you suggest?
“Did the narrator know Kipplin in real life before he told his story about David? Was it just a coincidence that David and the narrator went to college together? I feel like it isn’t entirely clear within the story. I think if it was more clear the relationship between the narrator and Kipplin outside of RuneScape—if there is one—then it would put the plot in a better direction. “
08-May-2011 15:46:14