Forums

~~The Priceless~~

Quick find code: 49-50-890-60645640

Venmi

Venmi

Posts: 14,744 Opal Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
Character Development -- 48/50 -- The characters are expertly crafted! It felt like they were real people from beginning to end. The coolest thing was where you learn about Alex Kipplin, and the outfit he wears is much like the one his character wears on RuneScape. The personification of his actual appearance on a video game is something that will only be noticed by those who actually know him and his struggles.
David is a character that put anger and bitterness in my heart. He is a guy who makes love nothing more than a hopeless fantasy. He takes everything for granted, and it is a sickening sight. The depth put into him—or I should say the depth that was never needed to be put into him—shows how much of an ass he really is.
The narrator seems to be a mysterious guy. He makes the reader question his past, his motives, and his intentions. He seems like a good guy who is trying to help those in need, but some of the actions in his past*not noted, but referenced in some way*could possibly indicate the darker side of him. He said that he and David had a few things and common, and that could say he is a darker person than he make himself to be.
Total -- 180/200 -- Overall, The Priceless is what it’s titled: priceless. It is a mesmerizing story that tugs at the heart strings and won’t let go. It makes the reader think about love and what it means to him/her. Not only that, it shows what love truly means. It is something that can’t be given. One must earn it through determination, motivation, and hard work. Thank you, English, for writing a story that shows the meaning of love. This is a story that will die when the stories forum does. It is just that good.
~Mitch

08-May-2011 00:31:24 - Last edited on 08-May-2011 00:41:02 by Venmi

Englishkid62

Englishkid62

Posts: 9,782 Rune Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
Hey, Mitch. Thank you for the timely and thorough review. I have enjoyed reading it and I am glad you enjoyed the story. I really liked some of the suggestions you put forth. Do bear in mind that this is quite an old work of mine (in fact, my first story in this forum) and there were creative/artistic choices I have made that I wouldn’t make today. Myself a perfectionist, I am extremely fastidious about where I put or don’t put commas, depending on the ‘music’ of the reading voice, which is why I have not taken all of the suggestions on board but I have given each a considerable amount of thought (and after all this time, my perception on what is the perfect music also changes) and will apply these changes in the story soon.
I find your review quite interesting, actually. The Priceless (you may disagree with me on this one) is a story that means different things to different people. I mean, ever since it was written readers and reviewers alike tell me of their take on the story, some take away the lesson of ‘Don’t obsess over someone’, ‘Too irrational of Kipplin…’, ‘The ugly truth of our lives’, ‘This is a beautiful story of love’ – as you can imagine, a variety of comments. It seemed very reader-directed because perhaps the story reflects what is already there in the reader, and the reader see in the story his/her own reflection. There’s no particular lesson one needs to take from it, but rather, everyone sees something different. I as an author of course really liked all these different takes on the subject. I’m really glad that you were able to find something in it that sings to you too.

08-May-2011 15:45:57

Englishkid62

Englishkid62

Posts: 9,782 Rune Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
For the description, I don’t know about you, but many reviewers have criticized the lack of it. They’d say that I did*’t devote paragraphs describing Kipplin’s mansion, or RuneScape, or the college, or most things. In terms of actual textural details of each object is not given very much attention. So, on that day at the bench I could have described the colour of the sky, the clouds, the grass, and so on. I’m glad however, that you found it sufficient!
“This entire paragraph almost made me cry. I am currently a “David.” “
Really? In what sense? Many readers told me they least identify with David, and identify with either the narrator or Kipplin. It really is fascinating. Would you mind me asking why you are a ‘David’? Not to mention David is perhaps the most hated character in the story, lol!
“There is one thing that bothered me, and it is a very minor detail. It was during the part where the narrator is in Kipplin’s house. The description is nice, but the demon butler doesn’t seem to be getting enough credit. You mention how nice everything in the house is, and the demon butler kind of seems like a patch of dirt. Yes, it’s there and it could help in some way, but it doesn’t get the significance it deserves.’
--Interesting. When I wrote this I never gave the demon butler much thought, except perhaps it was a hint of a demon in Kipplin, or that a demon butler emphasises how imposing this person is, or simply because it was the best butler available in game. What sort of significance would you suggest?
“Did the narrator know Kipplin in real life before he told his story about David? Was it just a coincidence that David and the narrator went to college together? I feel like it isn’t entirely clear within the story. I think if it was more clear the relationship between the narrator and Kipplin outside of RuneScape—if there is one—then it would put the plot in a better direction. “

08-May-2011 15:46:14

Englishkid62

Englishkid62

Posts: 9,782 Rune Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
--To answer your question, Kipplin and the narrator never met each other in real life. They were only ‘online friends’. To the narrator, Kipplin could well be an ugly sod but the narrator did*’t so much care. I’d like to think of it as a coincidence that David and the narrator went to the same college (btw, in the UK ‘college’ means sixth form, which is when people in the US do AP English Lit etc.), and if Kipplin weren’t so devoted to Runescape, he’d be studying in the same place too. Keeping Kipplin an online, elusive identity makes this story more haunting, I think.
As for the originality…well, I simply detest violence and gore and that kind of thing :P . By keeping Runescape as a game and the story focusing on the people behind it, it makes the story more real, don’t you think? It can be much more compelling to the reader if they know that it is plausible this can happen, particularly with the writing tone I have selected for the school ground scenes.
I’m really glad that is has touched you. Over many drafts and revisions, I become immune to the story and often forget its impact on unsuspecting readers. Were you expecting something like this when you began reading? Most people were completely unaware. I recall a couple of individual who was able to shut off their emotions and tell I should see a doctor and read the bible, but the overwhelming majority appreciated the story. I’m really glad that you do, too. While when this story was conceived I was just getting the hang of invoking emotions, this still remained one of my more successful works. Maybe it’s just the story, I don’t know. Here I learned how to tug at a reader’s heart. I hadn’t yet known how to reduce a reader into a sobbing wreck :P

08-May-2011 15:46:30

Englishkid62

Englishkid62

Posts: 9,782 Rune Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
“The coolest thing was where you learn about Alex Kipplin, and the outfit he wears is much like the one his character wears on RuneScape. The personification of his actual appearance on a video game is something that will only be noticed by those who actually know him and his struggles.”
--Haha! I actually did*’t think much of this during the first draft, when this idea was conceived. I simply thought it was a nice idea, and wrote it down. I definitely haven’t anticipated the amount of people who liked this detail.
“The narrator seems to be a mysterious guy. He makes the reader question his past, his motives, and his intentions.”
--I have deliberately kept him fairly mysterious for several artistic choices. In one draft I did*’t even have the narrator named in any way. Having a mysterious narrator, and because the reader is experiencing the story inside his body for the whole duration of 32 posts, he can’t do anything that the reader would not empathise with. Then again, I want to emphasise that this narrator can be anyone. It can even be the reader themselves. What would the reader have done, were they in his position?
“Thank you, English, for writing a story that shows the meaning of love.”
--Well, I thank you for your time, and reviewing this work :)
Here are some notes and reflections on your review, and for myself as well when I correct it later.
“RuneScape provided an ethereal, fantasy world in which no one would ever tell me what to do.”
To me, it sounds better if it’s an ethereal fantasy world instead of an ethereal, fantasy world. The fantasy world is ethereal, so a comma doesn’t seem necessary.
--The reading voice demanded a pause after ethereal. Just to make it absolutely clear that when readers read it aloud, I want a pause there (Part of the music-making of reading, I guess you could say), I added the comma. It was a stylistic choice.
“Drinking was our passion too. It was fun, it numbed the pain and consciousness.”

08-May-2011 15:46:48

Quick find code: 49-50-890-60645640 Back to Top