Alright, Ranthar.
Your plot, while young, did show some certain aspects of creativity; it was relatively simple, but with enough room for growth that I was suitably impressed (the Strider -- err, "Saint", chapter not withstanding: you're not fooling anyone, buddy).
However, I did have a major problem with your story, and it was your inability to correctly or consistently apply the basic rules of the English language to writing. Your commas, quotation marks, paragraphing, and even capitalization were an unmitigated disaster. You seriously, seriously need to proofread the story. They're not complicated issues, so there should be no problem fixing them, but yikes. Proofreading is your friend, maybe your best friend, and you seriously need to renew the ties between you guys.
Due to that, I can welcome you to The Amethyst Library with the rank of Penman. Fix up the errors in grammar and spelling, re-apply, and I can't imagine that you won't be able to climb to a more prestigious rank, one more representative of your true story-telling abilities.
03-Aug-2011 09:51:07