-=[ATTENTION]=-
Hello contestants!
The Deadline has now passed.
I am about to release the results for the contest. I’d like to point a few things out first.
One is that, as a judge, it is my duty to be honest with you and critique each of your stories in a fair fashion.
If I was to treat one or more of you more nicely because I thought you might be hurt if I said something bad about your story, this would be unfair to the other contestants.
Also, if I was to treat one of you different because I like you, this would be unfair to the other contestants.
As such, your grades represent my opinions of your stories. NOT my opinion of you as a writer or as a person, so don’t take things too personally.
Also, the grades were mostly based on my objective opinion about the storys, and in case people are wondering, I did*’t use any formula for deducting points, but I did explain the reasons for my choices of scores, based on the general outline in the rubric.
Here are the stories, reviewed and scored, in the order of their original posting.
NOTE: Each of these reviews is directed entirely to the author. When I say “you” in the review, I mean whoever wrote the story, because I want them to get the most out of their reviews.
An overview of the scores is as follows:
Poetic Sigil: 35/45
Raising Hawk: 34/45
ITIalevolent: 33/45
The Level: 32/45
NoMercyMan1: 32/45
Lord Ogre5th: 32/45
Rao Bear: 30/45
DragoonR**er: 19/45
10-May-2010 02:01:41
- Last edited on
10-May-2010 04:58:34
by
Logan Shafts