Forums

Well Told Tales

Quick find code: 49-50-636-60690976

Logan Shafts
Dec Member 2023

Logan Shafts

Posts: 3,211 Adamant Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
Guthix Sigil: Here is the review you requested.
First of all, this was a very touching story. You detail the relationship between your two main characters nicely – and in such a short story, that is difficult. Good work.
There were a few minor grammatical errors, as follows.
You wrote: …Then said, "Little brother, be strong. I will always be with you when you need me."…
This should be *then said” – I understand the word limit, but as it is that is a sentence fragment.
You can do this without going over the word limit by taking another word out in the following sentence: “You will die if you stay” can be made “You’ll die if you stay” – this removes one word and leaves the same meaning.
You wrote: "Then come with us; protect him." – As a general rule, you shouldn’t use semicolons inside of quote marks.
They are a writing tool and not a speaking tool, so I don’t think it’s correct to use them in speech or dialogue. You do this also in the next sentence “if I fight hard enough;” etcetera.
Now, for more stylistic objections:
In my opinion the first paragraph in this story is kind of weak – at least in that is repeats *stood there” over and over. You are trying to convey a point, but even so diversity of wording is important for any story.
You wrote: “…Markuth stood there,” then “He stood there,” and then again “He stood there, …”
The first question of the reader is likely to be “Stood where?” – One which you don’t answer.
Obviously, putting in any description of his surroundings is out of the question because of the word limit, but instead of repeating “stood there” you might add different descriptive gestures.

11-Apr-2010 21:00:23

Logan Shafts
Dec Member 2023

Logan Shafts

Posts: 3,211 Adamant Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
For instance (though I won’t rewrite your story), you simplify the first paragraph to save words.
To do this, just get rid of the ‘stood there’ and combine the sentences a bit. This saves words for later in the story.
Another instance in the story where I suggest diversifying words is in the very last paragraph.
You wrote: “…never let me fade from your heart." He spun back around and left. Emptying his heart,” …
Instead of using heart twice in such close quarters, you might replace the word with a synonym or something close to one, like “Spirit”, or “soul”, or even “emptying himself”. Thesaurus’ are great for this task (Google it).
There were a few things about comma splicing I noticed, but I don't have time to go deep into that. You might try reading the story outloud to yourself and see if you need to remove commas or add them. This is more about the desires of the writer anyways, because it's about how your story reads (which makes it stylistic), and there are many different styles.
Remember, all of this is just my opinion about it – if you like it as it is, keep it that way. It is your story, lol.
The fact that this is all I could grunge up to critique about your story is good, it was well written and enticing, though sad.
Good job. =]

11-Apr-2010 21:00:58 - Last edited on 11-Apr-2010 21:04:08 by Logan Shafts

Sam Orahk

Sam Orahk

Posts: 32 Bronze Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
Logan, could you, perhaps, give some feedback on this one?
I tried my best to make it as good English as possible, but, being a Dutchy doesn't make it easy. The feedback could be a very good help improving my skills in the English language :P .
So, here goes nothing:
--The Meiyerditch Assault--
Zebeshiel Kru’llian was walking down the path to the main tent. This was getting out of hand. “The third attack in two days; don’t those bloodsuckers know when to stop?!”, he said to himself while he was approaching the quarters of the commander, master Jhallan. The Mahjarrat general always made him shiver a little whenever Zebeshiel was close to him. But, as it was, being a lieutenant in the Zamorakian Army, you had to report things to your superiors. And today, it was bad news. The Vyrewatch squads had attacked the forces of Zamorak again this morning, this time killing a few hundreds of them, including a mage. The Meiyerditch assault had turned out to be worse than expected, and Zamorak himself was getting restless of the little progress they made. Although the city walls were taken down, the castle was still standing firm on the hill. It was a crucial point in the battle: once they conquered the castle, the way to Phasmatys was fully open, and with that the domination of the Morytania region a fact.
Once he arrived at the tent, Zebeshiel walked to his general’s throne directly. He was having a conversation with several other generals, including the just arrived lord Lucien, Zamorak’s right hand. Extra troops were needed, and Lucien was known for his extraordinary necromancy skills. Skeleton warriors flooded the camp by thousands, and Lucien himself came and sent mages into the region beyond the bridge of Mort’ton. But Zebeshiel had no time to think of what may be happening at the other side of that bridge, he needed to tell Jhallan of the attack of the Vyrewatch.

12-Apr-2010 18:08:42

Sam Orahk

Sam Orahk

Posts: 32 Bronze Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
Zebeshiel bowed. “My lord, I…” he started, but Jhallan interrupted him: “I know of which you came here to speak. Lucien’s mage returned.” Zebeshiel turned his face, to see a man, clad in black and holding a staff, watching them from under his hood. “He saw the Vyrewatch assault, and was nearly killed. His companion, as you know, did*’t make it. However, nonetheless, they succeeded.” Jhallan stopped. “We will win the next battle, Kru’llian. I’m sure of it.” And with a smile on his ‘face’, Jhallan walked away.
Zebeshiel returned slowly to his own quarters. “They succeeded,” the general said. So it was true. The Barrows were unsealed. “Now things will get interesting”, thought the lieutenant, while he prepared himself for another assault.

Hope you liked it, thanks on beforehand ^_^

12-Apr-2010 18:09:17

Guthix Sigil

Guthix Sigil

Posts: 209 Silver Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
Thanks for the review Logan! ^_^
When I asked for you to not be too harsh in the last post, I just meant to not say something along the lines of 'it lacks description' or the such, when obviously I was being challenged to be under 400 words. You did account for that in your review so thank you.
Thank you for the semicolon tidbit, I never knew that. As far as commas go, I am terribly addicted to them (although I try to sound out what I am writing to prevent overdoing it too much) and I know that I may post a few unnecessary ones, so I ask you to please cope with them while reading my stories. ;)
As for the introduction, I was trying to emphasize on how small his world seemed at the time. "He stood there (epic line here)" "He stood there (epic line here)" "He stood there (epic finishing line here)". I have gotten a few comments about this, so I may change it around and neglect using it until I know how to use it to its full potential. As for the repeating 'hearts' at the end, I saw that myself, but was too lazy at the time to come up with a word that meant the same as what I was trying to portray (soul and spirit just do not sound right to me).
Well, if you have read all this, thanks. I really appreciate the review as well. I hope to talk to you again soon.
May your words be the sharpest of Blades,
-Guthix Sigil

14-Apr-2010 01:39:25

Quick find code: 49-50-636-60690976 Back to Top