Forums

¥ Yrolg's Reviews ¥

Quick find code: 49-50-196-58521317

Yrolg

Yrolg

Posts: 25,296 Sapphire Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
Very well, Wintry Elf. Your application's acceptance has been rescinded. Having not breached any of the written rules, however, you *may* apply again as soon as you like. =)

ATTENTION ALL POTENTIAL APPLICANTS:
I will hereby be accepting one, single application of the correct format to be reviewed by this establishment. Please remember when posting that the applications must follow all posted rules and guidelines.
Thank you.

10-Apr-2009 04:55:34 - Last edited on 10-Apr-2009 04:56:12 by Yrolg

WintryElf

WintryElf

Posts: 1,194 Mithril Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
Hello.

Username: Wintry Elf
Story Title: Quadmagus
Quick Find Code: 49-50-373-58594382
Type of Story: Unfinished Story
Length: currently 13 posts
May I post this review on your story: Yes.

Literary Tools: 116.5/150
--Description: 24/40
--Voice: 23/25
--Symbolism: 14/25
--Depth: 16.5/20
--Analysis: 16/20
--Word Choice: 16/20
--Juxtaposition: 7/10

Structure: 113/120
--Format: 37/40
--Grammar: 30/30
--Usage: 18/20
--Sentence Configuration: 13/15
--Basics: 15/15
Plot: 54/100
--Development: 20/40
--Intricacy: 10/30
--Consistency: 11/15
--Originality: 13/15
Other: 70.5/90 -
--Impact: 17.5/20
--Flow: 15/20
--Conclusion: (N/A since it hasn’t ended yet?) 8/15
--Theme: 13/15
--Empathetic Ties: 7/10
--Title Relevance: 10/10
Layout: 72/80
--Introduction: 30/30
--Overall Appearance: 18/20
--Title Page: 11/15
--Chapter Configuration: 13/15

Total: 137/520
(Hoping I caught all the keywords again~! Grr!)
Elfie

10-Apr-2009 05:05:35

The contents of this message have been hidden.

10-Apr-2009 05:10:02

Yrolg

Yrolg

Posts: 25,296 Sapphire Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
Wintry Elf,
Hello. I see that you have applied again. All seems well with your application, and you indeed managed to capture most of my hidden phrases.
Congratulations on being accepted as the next story to be reviewed in Yrolg's Reviews. You may expect your review by April 25th, a date subject to change.
Thank you.

ATTENTION ALL POTENTIAL APPLICANTS:
Applications are now closed. =)

10-Apr-2009 15:29:16

Yrolg

Yrolg

Posts: 25,296 Sapphire Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
Hello, Carrotman714. The following, as requested, is my review of your story “Agony”. Please feel free to respond to any point that I made, and question any of my decisions. Please also be aware of the necessary information needed to have me change your overall score.
“"Mummy...?" one child cried out, disturbed by their parent's disappearance. “
The word “their” is a plural possessive. You should use it when the subject possessing the object(s) is plural. For example: “The boys remembered their shoes.” In your usage of this word, you were showing the possession of “one child”. This is singular and you should therefore use the phrase “his or her”:
““Mummy…?” one child cried out, disturbed by her parents’ disappearance.”
You will notice also that I changed the location of the apostrophe. You should note that apostrophes, with relation to possession, are to be used as follows:
Singular possession is to be shown by the addition of ‘s at the end of the noun, regardless of the final consonant.
“Marissa’s sarcasm earned her those three days of detention with Ms. M*Clair.”
Plural possession is to be shown by the addition of s’ at the end of the noun, regardless of the final consonant, constrained to abstinence for irregulars.
“The boys’ desks were a display of artful graffiti whilst nature and kindness adorned the girls’ desks.”
The following are quotes from “The Elements of Style”.

13-Apr-2009 17:33:32 - Last edited on 18-Dec-2009 21:15:04 by Yrolg

Yrolg

Yrolg

Posts: 25,296 Sapphire Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
“The pronominal possessives hers, its, theirs, yours, and oneself have no apostrophe.”
“They. A common inaccuracy is the use of the plural pronoun when the antecedent is a distributive expression such as each, each one, everybody, every one, many a man,which, though implying more than one person, requires the pronoun to be in the singular. Similar to this, but with even less justification, is the use of the plural pronoun with the antecedent anybody, any one, somebody, some one, the intention being either to avoid the awkward "he or she," or to avoid committing oneself to either. Some bashful speakers even say, "A friend of mine told me that they, etc."”

“"MUMMY!!" the terrified child from before cried fiercely from inside one of the houses south of the bank, breaking the bunch into a horrified frenzy and bringing the topic of Veronica's presence to a halt. Mad dashes towards the house were made, Veronica and Jaden being swept up in their parents arms to avoid them being trampled by anxious citizens.”
I am not fond of this particular paragraph. The first mistake I note is that you include two exclamation marks at the end of “MUMMY”. You should reserve using this style of punctuation for only the most appropriate circumstances. Using two exclamation marks emphasizes to a great extent the magnitude of the yell. Your following commentary on whence this cry came and the ensuing action is, to be frank, not at all complimentary to this.
Secondly, I really find the line “child from before” to be execrable. It is utterly vague, nondescript, and confusing to the reader. The child from before could be Veronica, who you are now not naming, or it could be any other child thus-far insinuated into the story.

13-Apr-2009 17:33:56

Yrolg

Yrolg

Posts: 25,296 Sapphire Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
You also have this commentary as a run-on sentence. You tried to incorporate too many ideas in between full-stops. Sentences should contain the minimum number of topics needed to conduct flow properly. This sentence contains three main ideas, each completely separate. As a sequence of events, I would suggest putting each action into its own sentence:
“MUMMY!” a terrified child, way up in one of the southern houses, bellowed. Breaking the crowd into a horrified frenzy, the cry also brought the topic of Veronica’s presence to a complete and utter halt.”
Your second sentence I also dislike. Whilst I appreciate that you are trying to convey the panic, imbroglio, and disarray formed from the sudden cry, I must begin to question exaggeration when you use such phrases as “Mad dashes” and “trampled by anxious citizens”. I suggest rethinking the ferocity of panic in this particular scene. If indeed the level of panic is at such a level as to cause the children to be trampled, I don’t mind this. I think, however, that it would be best to not use my above quote or anything similar to it; fiercer, more exaggerative words are more called for.
“Written on the wall below the window in blood was one word.
Agony.
And that's when it all began.
From then on, Edgeville became a haunted town.”
I think that you were doing a wonderful job leading up to a very ground-breaking, question-answering (and –forming) pinnacle in this prologue until you did what I like to explain as the following:
“The End.
But not really.
There’s actually more.
Or is there?
No, really, there’s more.
It was a good trick, though, eh?”
Your prologue is meant to introduce the topic of your story to the audience. It is generally a good idea to end in a very impacting manner. Personally, I would have simply left the prologue at “Agony”, and I would have incorporated the following information into a later portion of the story, where it is more appropriate and less distracting.

13-Apr-2009 17:34:12

Quick find code: 49-50-196-58521317 Back to Top