I did say this is a discussion for elsewhere; as such, here it comes. The current 75% system is a bias and unjust system in which, we the players, had no say. Because of this, we the players, are the ones now suffering from its consequences. I will list a few of the arguments below.
1.) 74% Upset players outweighs 26% Satisfied / Vengeance hungry voters?
I've concluded from a conversation with Mod Ash that his opinion is as such. "If the majority of the players vote for it, I support it." So is it fair to crush 74% of the players upon a poll? Many of those who vote no often have a bias against the particular content in question; more on this below.
2.) Different Play Styles:
Runescape is comprised of several niches of players. We've got the bank standing / social players, clan communities, marketing and merchanting communities, pure communities, skillers, PvP'ers and PvM'ers; only to name a FEW! With each different style of enjoying the game comes different opinions. A pure obviously wont want the same content as a main. This creates an immediate spiteful bias at each and every poll that does not cater to each and all of the communities.
3.) Jagex's Struggle:
Lately, I have noticed every content piece be overly hyped in an attempt to create a interest among the community. Dev Blogs, Hyped up twitter, Twitch streams and Q&A's, multiple Surveys and Polls! This may be because of how harsh we bash every piece of content. Jagex has to work on each proposal! All of that work gets wasted as does their time! Think of all the work Mod Reach would have wasted if Corporeal Beast just gets destroyed at poll?
4.) Oldschool is OLDSCHOOL
A short, but sure percentage of players with the total level to do so will bring their NO's to the poll. Just because they want no change, ever, period.
5.) Understanding the content:
Simply put, some players just don't understand the content in question. = Dev Blogs.