Forums

Dev blog: Trading Solution V2 Thread is locked

Quick find code: 380-381-34-65435513

Nezzaris
Apr Member 2020

Nezzaris

Posts: 119 Iron Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
If Jagex is debating on trying to reincorporate a trading system than it might as well be all or nothing. Back when the first trade update came out Jagex probably lost at least 1/3rd of it's dedicated players and members (My friends and myself included). What brought me back, as well as my friends, was hearing that the old Runescape we had known and loved was back, no trade restrictions, no Grand Exchange, just going through the community trying to find the items you need. Is it harder this way? Of course, but the game and the community as well is much less enjoyable when you have everything sitting at a few clicks of a mouse. Not to mention that much of the community thrives off of the current market in what is typically referred to as "flipping" certain items to become wealthy. After all, wasn't this one of the main reasons in bringing back OSRS? Along with the combat revolution of course. It essentially defeats the purpose of having OSRS. It is comparable to adding a trading system onto Classic. Doesn't that sound absurd? How far are we away from OSRS seeing it's own combat update as well? (Hopefully that never happens) My point being that, in the end, someone is going to be unhappy. However, Jagex needs to proceed here with caution. They could see a rapid decline in players by releasing any sort of trading system, but if they choose to maintain the status quo, I doubt they'd see the same reaction because most of us are content with OSRS the way it is. Sure, it would be easier with a trading system, but some of us don't want the easy way out here. If you're someone pushing for a trading system, you have RS3 right there that you should be playing and getting used to, instead of trying to ruin a classic era for Runescape back in it's prime.

If Jagex is thinking of adding a trading system, they might as well just re-instate the Grand Exchange, because as soon as any trading update is released they will see large margin of dedicated players leave.

~Nezzaris~

31-May-2014 17:54:30

Puff Puff It

Puff Puff It

Posts: 7 Bronze Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
this vote should have to be 75% yes to pass, not everyone wants the game to be super easy and when the 07 servers were originally coming out i was under the impression it was for 07 players, it was voted to keep updating and fixing bugs, etc. but i don't think anyone who voted on that was looking for a grand exchange. any true 07 player that actually liked 07 should easily agree the GE is the game ruiner that haunted EOC and maybe a system to get items a little faster may be nice but takin the the bartering out makes it less personal, and actually looking for in game items builds community, adding something like that is not a update, it changes the entire mechanics of the game. the true 07 players like 07 runescape, not Eoc, soon the only difference will be the overrides and the hotkeys. so i please ask you before you decide to personally ruin the best idea since 2007 to me reconsider what your doing to the entire mechanics of the game and what people miss and love.

31-May-2014 18:05:47 - Last edited on 31-May-2014 21:47:28 by Puff Puff It

Eldne

Eldne

Posts: 15 Bronze Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
Yeah, I love standing in a spot for hours and auto-typing. I am totally "interacting with the community".
Not to mention the huge loads of spam in the chat that make it impossible to find the item you are buying or selling.

I agree that OSRS should not lose its nostalgic feel, but when you are questing or in a rush, it is convenient to have a quick way to buy it.

31-May-2014 18:55:37 - Last edited on 31-May-2014 18:56:10 by Eldne

Nezzaris
Apr Member 2020

Nezzaris

Posts: 119 Iron Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
I completely agree with where you're coming from. However it's also nice not to have a set price on that item you're trying to buy and being able to negotiate a price if you are tight on cash. Also, when I refer to interacting with the community, I understand that's not usually the case in West Varrock, but adding something similar to the Grand Exchange takes away the casual "Hey anyone have a Mith Pick I could buy?" at a common bank. It takes away a lot from the experience because now whenever you need something you just go to the GE. You isolate yourself and in turn the game becomes less enjoyable.

31-May-2014 19:10:15

Eldne

Eldne

Posts: 15 Bronze Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
Original message details are unavailable.
I completely agree with where you're coming from. However it's also nice not to have a set price on that item you're trying to buy and being able to negotiate a price if you are tight on cash. Also, when I refer to interacting with the community, I understand that's not usually the case in West Varrock, but adding something similar to the Grand Exchange takes away the casual "Hey anyone have a Mith Pick I could buy?" at a common bank. It takes away a lot from the experience because now whenever you need something you just go to the GE. You isolate yourself and in turn the game becomes less enjoyable.

Thats true :P but remember that the GE is where most people hang out with their friends. RuneScape was created to be played both single-player and multiplayer ;)

31-May-2014 19:14:56

Nezzaris
Apr Member 2020

Nezzaris

Posts: 119 Iron Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
Exactly my point! :D Too many people waste their time with friends sitting at the GE when they could be questing/skilling together! Plus it becomes much harder to make new friends when you don't trade with anyone, of course you have the same friends you have in real life, but it's nice to have a lot of active people in your friends list if you ever need anything. Most people don't really make new friends anymore, and that also plays a big role in how fast you can get bored! Many of my friends I have met while trading! Another reason I think the trade update would be pointing us in the wrong direction.

31-May-2014 19:42:41

Andrew Vin
Oct Member 2022

Andrew Vin

Posts: 10,829 Opal Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
Original message details are unavailable.
I completely agree with where you're coming from. However it's also nice not to have a set price on that item you're trying to buy and being able to negotiate a price if you are tight on cash. Also, when I refer to interacting with the community, I understand that's not usually the case in West Varrock, but adding something similar to the Grand Exchange takes away the casual "Hey anyone have a Mith Pick I could buy?" at a common bank. It takes away a lot from the experience because now whenever you need something you just go to the GE. You isolate yourself and in turn the game becomes less enjoyable.


That negotiating, to me, is a bad thing. If someone tries to haggle with me, they're on my ignore list and I teleport, no second chances. My listed price on **b is not a suggested price.

31-May-2014 21:09:31

Ninstud

Ninstud

Posts: 3 Bronze Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
A good portion of the OSRS community doesn’t want person-to-person trading to become obsolete as it has in RS3. If the option to trade though the trading post passes we should re-poll the trading post tax (e.g. 5-10% of price). It may have failed miserably in the earlier poll, but at that point it wasn’t clear if the trading post would be simply a place to post the buy/sell offers or if it would execute the trades like the GE.

Also, if we ever add free-to-play to OSRS we should definitely do a poll before allowing free players to use the trading post.

31-May-2014 21:19:26

Dwilly

Dwilly

Posts: 526 Steel Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
Yes the GE will truly kill the real RuneScape Vibes I and many others are here for. I will go back to just RuneScape Classic if they Ruin OldSchool lol the sameeeee way they RUINED RS after 06! It was 200k online in 06

31-May-2014 22:15:11

Quick find code: 380-381-34-65435513 Back to Top