Until more information is provided I am leaning towards no, while I love the concept I also loved the concept of a dominion tower minigame...and melee lost all integrity and getting rid of randoms sounded great...and now magics a joke.
If the concept does pass I have a few recommendations.
1) make the exp rates low reaching like 40k/h maximum at higher levels, tbh as this is a "fun" skill it should probably be lower, the sailing cape should be an accomplishment.
2) make it such that as a solo player you must click more intensively but only get slightly more exp than as a group, this would mean that for absoloute max rates you have to focus a large ammount but can do it alone, and for a more leisurly experience you can band together with other players with slightly lower exp rates than solo (based on team mates performance).
3) add some RNG to the minigame, like a chance at facing a sea monster type boss which requires 95 slayer and has a very small chance of dropping a weildable item that helps with sailing (similar to how you could randomly get hexhunters and ssh in dung).
12-Aug-2015 23:12:34