This is a terrible idea, it totally negates the 'rarity' of these items if you are able to get them year after year.
Seriously re-consider your way of implementing these items or you will lose a lot more of your already dwindling OldSchool community.
The whole point of OldSchool was that you would listen to the community and do only what they wanted. Please re-release a poll with all previous drop ideas in one question, and whichever option gets the most votes, follow that. (Or if 2/3 are all close, use those 2/3 ideas for implementing different items - e.g. Phats through treasure trails, Halloween Masks through holiday drops etc.)
You are introducing the rares in a way that no-one voted, and it is clear from the responses here and on other forums (Check Reddit; you have a strong base of frequent players on /r/2007scape) that this is not the way to go about introducing rares.
17-May-2013 18:01:25