I personally think that the whole point for having an 'Oldschool server' was for the appearance to look nostalgic - to make players feel as though they're playing the game in 2007. That said, I do like aspects of the new designs, but I think the theme ends up following the one that the main game took in late 2011. To possibly please the majority of the community, a design could be created that doesn't match either the really old theme or the new Runescape 3 theme - but fits in with the website with aspects such as more detailed shading and the placement of the navigation bar. However, I personally feel it would suit the oldschool site more to keep the current colour scheme but modify the layout so that it suits the main site for the game. Then, not only do you keep the nostalgic colours, but you also please a large percentage of the community that also want the website to appear 'newer' as well as retain the retro style.
24-Apr-2015 18:57:38