Forums

Xau-Tak: God of the Horrors

Quick find code: 341-342-37-65701262

Wahisietel
Oct Member 2005

Wahisietel

Posts: 3,426 Adamant Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
Zulkir said :
Wahisietel said :
At this point I'm fairly sure it's either completely random or linked to having a specific number of cave goblins alive.


Goblins, nope.

Random? Maybe, But what'd be the point?

Likely requires a relevant quest to be completed.

Is there anyone with a quest cape that didn't get the dialogue?


I have a master quest cape. I didn't get the dialogue.
You never were our brightest star, Khazard. 'Vermin slaughtered like lambs'? What does that even mean?

16-Feb-2016 14:39:30

The Mather1
May Member 2008

The Mather1

Posts: 1,172 Mithril Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
I have a quest cape (or had until the release, haven't been able to beat Nomad) and was wearing Grotesque Armor (tier 2 to be specific) and I did not get the dialogue either.

I spared Zanik in TMF and speared Nomad in DAT.
"Abscondita est in Astra."

16-Feb-2016 19:36:43 - Last edited on 16-Feb-2016 19:37:46 by The Mather1

Mazakon

Mazakon

Posts: 3,288 Adamant Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
Wahisietel said :
Zulkir said :
Wahisietel said :
At this point I'm fairly sure it's either completely random or linked to having a specific number of cave goblins alive.


Goblins, nope.

Random? Maybe, But what'd be the point?

Likely requires a relevant quest to be completed.

Is there anyone with a quest cape that didn't get the dialogue?


I have a master quest cape. I didn't get the dialogue.


That's odd. While I don't have the MQC requirements, I do have every other quest completed. Also, I had 3 goblins remaining. I still got the dialogue.
The pirates of the Granblue set sail!

16-Feb-2016 23:45:42

Lego Miester
Nov Member 2023

Lego Miester

Posts: 35,339 Sapphire Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
Granted a god being behind it is certainly a fair interpretation, as there's definitely something with that skeletal horrors, the black masks, and the zombies that's all tied together. (we even know at this point the zombies are made using black rock 'rum') but I interpreted it as being the abyss. You know, with the tendrils, and it also coming out in 2005. Headcanon Haven, where everything is made up and the points don't matter.
OSRS Lore: Xeric
Slepe Tight - Slepe Lore

17-Feb-2016 00:23:37

Balustan

Balustan

Posts: 19,291 Opal Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
Lego Miester said :
Granted a god being behind it is certainly a fair interpretation, as there's definitely something with that skeletal horrors, the black masks, and the zombies that's all tied together. (we even know at this point the zombies are made using black rock 'rum') but I interpreted it as being the abyss. You know, with the tendrils, and it also coming out in 2005.


Wouldn't Black Rock rum be made using black rock fragments like the Ex-Ex Parrot used to eat? Those come from the horror mask slab. It seems to me there is a connection but there may be very different stories. Basically the Chthulu Mythos stuff, there is black stone in the Chthulu Mythos, facilitates the means for the Pirate story to happen but isn't necessarily the same story. In fact that seems unlikely since Jagex want to wrap up Pirates in 1 more quest.
Lewis
|
Quester
|
Scottish

17-Feb-2016 01:19:04

Any-sao
Dec Member 2020

Any-sao

Posts: 2,424 Mithril Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
Well, after reading this… I really do not agree with it.

To avoid sugar coating:

Wahisietel: this is a bad theory. The Lore Forums have historically been used to discuss player predictions and ideas, but they generally have some strong reinforcement. Correct or otherwise, it generally ends up interesting.

This is not like those threads.

There is literally no link between Xau-Tak and pirates. You seem to be making your connection of extremely old content that was left somewhat open ended (by today's definition, anyway) and V's statement that Xau-Tak is on Gielinor. If I'm recapping correctly: you are basically listing all the different mysteries left from the pirate series, and then linking them to a character we literally have one sentence to describe.

By this logic, why don't we make other theories? I believe that monkey skull under Marim belongs to one of the unknown Guardians of Guthix. Or maybe the Karamja God is actually the leader of the Penguin Motherland? Or maybe Saradomin is blue because he's friends with Solomon…

Give me a few pages, and I can stretch out each of those into a theory.

I'm sorry, old friend. But this theory is incorrect!
I’m not great at this game, but I do love quests.

17-Feb-2016 06:43:29

Velia
Jan Member 2020

Velia

Posts: 2,836 Adamant Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
Any-sao said :
Wahisietel: this is a bad theory. The Lore Forums have historically been used to discuss player predictions and ideas, but they generally have some strong reinforcement. Correct or otherwise, it generally ends up interesting.

This is not like those threads.
So from this you're saying that this thread isn't discussing predictions and ideas, and is also uninteresting? I disagree with you. I think this thread fits right in with all the rest. This thread is clearly proposing predictions and ideas, though the "interesting" part is up to personal preference.

I've seen other threads on here based more on preference or flimsy connections getting quite a bit of support. Things like "The World Gate is the thing the Pest Queen came from!", "Gielinor's Elder Halls is the Rune Essence mine!", "Sliske is a lorefail!", "Lucien is Nomad's master!", "Loarnab is the presence in Tolna's Rift!".

All of the above things are speculation, much like this one, that have varying degrees of 'evidence'. Some dis-proven, some pending.

By your logic: Any-sao said :
There is literally no link between Xau-Tak and pirates. You seem to be making your connection of extremely old content that was left somewhat open ended (by today's definition, anyway) and V's statement that Xau-Tak is on Gielinor. If I'm recapping correctly: you are basically listing all the different mysteries left from the pirate series, and then linking them to a character we literally have one sentence to describe.
...You could say that there is literally no link between the Rune Essence mines and the Elder Halls, or Tolna's rift and Loarnab. Both of those are "extremely old content that [were] left somewhat open-ended" and linking it to something more recent that maybe relates to it.

So, in essence, speculation is pointless and we shouldn't do it because we're probably wrong.

Sounds like fun.

17-Feb-2016 10:13:43

Any-sao
Dec Member 2020

Any-sao

Posts: 2,424 Mithril Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
Mod Wilson said :
Any-sao said :
There is literally no link between Xau-Tak and pirates.


O RLY? ;)


Would you care to elaborate on that? Or does that really just mean "I like this theory. Maybe we'll incorporate it into the game."

If it's the latter; that is really not a good idea. Finishing a long and respected story by introducing a new character from the left-field to tie up loose ends makes for a poor story.

The proof is in the pudding: past quests that were received with standing applauses were those that tied up a story using characters we knew and had opinions on (Ritual of the Mahjarrat, for example). When a new character emerges to… let's say, "improve," a story, the quest staggers and becomes a little harder to receive. The Dark Lord from Plague's End received very mixed reviews. The character most definitely had a strong build-up, but the relative spontaneounty of the character's identity seemed odd, and stopped the story dead.

Then there's examples like Char and the Firemaker's Curse: Generally considered to be a good quest, Char was introduced all on her own. She later integrated herself into The World Wakes, and since then has become a staple Zarosian. If Firemaker's Curse was omitted, and Char was introduced in The World Wakes as a fiery Zarosian meant to tie up the loose end of Zaros' remaining non-Mahjarrat followers… then I doubt the quest would be as liked as it was.

The pirate finale should involve pirates. Not some new menace that the world is just now discovering is a threat.
I’m not great at this game, but I do love quests.

17-Feb-2016 18:48:52

Quick find code: 341-342-37-65701262 Back to Top