Well, after reading this… I really do not agree with it.
To avoid sugar coating:
Wahisietel: this is a bad theory. The Lore Forums have historically been used to discuss player predictions and ideas, but they generally have some strong reinforcement. Correct or otherwise, it generally ends up interesting.
This is not like those threads.
There is literally no link between Xau-Tak and pirates. You seem to be making your connection of extremely old content that was left somewhat open ended (by today's definition, anyway) and V's statement that Xau-Tak is on Gielinor. If I'm recapping correctly: you are basically listing all the different mysteries left from the pirate series, and then linking them to a character we literally have one sentence to describe.
By this logic, why don't we make other theories? I believe that monkey skull under Marim belongs to one of the unknown Guardians of Guthix. Or maybe the Karamja God is actually the leader of the Penguin Motherland? Or maybe Saradomin is blue because he's friends with Solomon…
Give me a few pages, and I can stretch out each of those into a theory.
I'm sorry, old friend. But this theory is incorrect!
I’m not great at this game, but I do love quests.
17-Feb-2016 06:43:29