Forums

I don't think you understand: yes, X alternate version might not satisfy everyone who desire after the original, but it'd satisfy some, and for those who weren't satisfied, Y, Z etc alternate versions, or even entirely new cosmetics, could be made, sooner or later satisfying the rest of them. Because the thing is that the human mind cannot fully comprehend something that doesn't yet exist, so while some people might even genuinely claim that only a certain cosmetic will ever satisfy them, that simply cannot be because true perfection like that does not exist. There can always be something else that you'll like more, you might just not realize it yet if you focus too much on what already exists and miss the forest for the trees.

There are people who desire something because they cannot have it, which is what I'd classify under "rarity desiring" because typically that is due to the desired thing being rare.

Yeah but again, people who want to own them for the memories should already have them: e.g. I have my memories of the 2011 Xmas event, and surprisingly, I also have the Xmas wand for having completed that event... because it was a reward for completing what I have memories of. If your account was banned or you otherwise lost access to it, again, that's unfortunate, but also kind of your responsibility, so it shouldn't be grounds for a rerelease.

I mean that's a fair point about decision-making, but it'd also make the historical value of the item lose it partially, because you wouldn't be able to tell anymore who originally earned the discontinued item.