Damn this would be a lot of fun
you could maybe have tasks, like to incorporate cb in it if higher levels wanted to train cb aswell.
like you talk to a Butcher.
"Hello, would you like a Butcher task?"
" Yes please!"
"Your task is to Butcher 23 cokroach soldiers"
By Butcher it means, kill, take the carcass and gutt it, with a vareity of different butchering tools, cleaver, crusher(for bones) Extractor, for poison.
Would love to see this in game and would love to actually help develop it.
Only flaw is people may find it offensive or gory, dont no y though
Sounds good, but instead of plain meat which the creature drops surely it would be more fitting for it to drop a carcass? You can then cut meat out of the carcass.
Adding to the idea:
Puffer-fish could be added - High level as in real life it takes a highly skilled cook to remove the poisonous sections
Lionfish - Poisonous spines and meat could be recovered. Poison could be extracted into vials to make weapon poison.
Poisonous bait could be used to help aid hunting (adding poison to meat), it would increase the chance of getting a successful capture
If you fail it causes damage to the player, this would limit the exp gained to stop it from becoming just another skill which can be power-trained (like fletching can be)
All in all, this seems like a good, if what slightly gory addition to runescape. I like it