Forums

New skill - Butchery

Quick find code: 185-186-918-62880567

Iso Decoder
Apr Member 2014

Iso Decoder

Posts: 2,873 Adamant Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
A very good idea. However, like some players advocated, I reckon this skill should be integrated into the cooking skill as most butchers are excellent cooks.
I don't support the notion that 'butchers don't cook.'

01-Aug-2012 02:18:25 - Last edited on 01-Aug-2012 02:19:33 by Iso Decoder

Iso Decoder
Apr Member 2014

Iso Decoder

Posts: 2,873 Adamant Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
I've just searched up the job description of a butcher:
1) Cuts, trims, bones, ties, and grinds meats, using butcher's cutlery and powered equipment, such as electric grinder and bandsaw, to portion and prepare meat in cooking form: Cuts, trims, and bones carcass sections or prime cuts, using knives, meat saw, cleaver, and bandsaw, to reduce to cooking cuts, such as roasts, steaks, chops, stew cubes, and grinding meat.
2) Cuts and weighs steaks and chops for individual servings.
3) Tends electric grinder to grind meat.
4) Shapes and ties roasts.
5) May estimate requirements and requisition or order meat supply.
6) May receive, inspect, and store meat upon delivery.
7) May record quantity of meat received and issued to cooks.
8) May clean fowl and fish.
9) May oversee other butchers and be designated Butcher, Head.
Oh wait...
... 'May record quantity of meat received and issued to cooks.'
Oops, sorry about my oversight, it appears that butchery and cooking are different occupations. Ok, in that case, I support.

01-Aug-2012 03:20:59

Stray Pup
Sep Member 2020

Stray Pup

Posts: 317 Silver Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
No need to get defensive, Scavlord, we're just here trying to provide help for your idea. What a lot of people are saying is that this runs closely alongside cooking and, maybe, the two should be integrated into a single skill.

01-Aug-2012 03:28:01

Scavlord
Jan Member 2008

Scavlord

Posts: 1,024 Mithril Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
For Tamriel, It's my job as the creator of this thread to defend my idea.
I hope that you would expect no less of me. But please don't confuse that defense as anger.
In real life the cook depends on the butcher for the raw materials that are used to create food. Just like the artist depends on the paint manufacturer to supply the paint. But their jobs are very different. Sure there are artists that make their own paints just as there are cooks that butcher their own meats but they are few and far between.
I can't imagine Jagex would put the work into butchery as an add-on to the already massively diverse skill of cooking. And I believe Jagex should be creating more skills, not one every 3 years or so. Butchery supports many other skills in the game and with different knives, cleavers, saws, butcher blocks (in your butchery room in your POH) it could even adds something new to smithing and construction.

04-Aug-2012 04:00:19

Quick find code: 185-186-918-62880567 Back to Top