Forums

~Disc. Items Discussion v1~

Quick find code: 17-18-536-66168267

4p
Dec Member 2007

4p

Posts: 967 Gold Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
nyxiah said :

Okay, are you sure that Santas weren't spawned AND dropped by the JMods for fun? because that is what was happening on OSRS. The hats were being spawned randomly around RS AND some jmods were dropping them too. This is what I was assuming happened in 2002 too, but sadly I wasn't playing back then to know the real fact, perhaps there is someone here who was playing back then and could tell us?


I'm unsure on the exact delivery method, but based on the Scythe drop it appears it was done manually and took up Andrew Gower's time to manually do it. We can assume that there wouldn't be a second-chance drop of Scythes if they were constantly on the ground (and therefore automatic) and we can assume from this that Santa Hats had the same delivery method. Random times, random places - not constantly available for players to continually collect all day long. We also wouldn't need a second-chance drop if 100k+ Scythes were in-game either.

I did believe that this was the delivery method - where you could go anywhere and collect a Holiday Item - but I was online for around 15 minutes the day Scythes were dropped and I never saw one (unfortunately!).

Andrew even says in his newspost " Don't be too upset if you can't find one " and " If you manage to get more than one then please consider giving them to a friend "
If the plan was to pump hundereds of thousands of them into the game, there shouldn't have been an issue 'managing to get more than one' or 'being too upset because you can't find one'

Regardless of everything, I don't believe Jagex had the capacity to pump 100k+ Santas into the game during the RSC era, let alone players collectively picking up 100k+ Santas and actively circulating that amount until 2009 onward.

I hope what I'm saying is making sense. There is definitely an abundance of Santa Hats, but I don't believe it's anywhere near 100k and I don't believe it was ever anywhere near 100k.

03-Jul-2020 17:58:29

Shn
Aug Member 2023

Shn

Posts: 406 Silver Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
4p said :


I'm unsure on the exact delivery method, but based on the Scythe drop it appears it was done manually and took up Andrew Gower's time to manually do it. We can assume that there wouldn't be a second-chance drop of Scythes if they were constantly on the ground (and therefore automatic) and we can assume from this that Santa Hats had the same delivery method. Random times, random places - not constantly available for players to continually collect all day long. We also wouldn't need a second-chance drop if 100k+ Scythes were in-game either.

I did believe that this was the delivery method - where you could go anywhere and collect a Holiday Item - but I was online for around 15 minutes the day Scythes were dropped and I never saw one (unfortunately!).


I think the manner in which they were dropped was a JMod would log in and enter a command i.e. "::drop". This would generate the item in the vicinity and then create a local system message "System Update: Happy Easter!" or whatever was relevant for the drop. The fact a system message was being generated suggests that there was server side code triggered to assist with the drop; the JMod didn't have to manually drop the items. I do however, agree that a JMod would have to be the one issuing the command in game.
Creator of RuneRares (no longer available). Been playing 15+ years.

03-Jul-2020 18:14:25 - Last edited on 03-Jul-2020 18:15:05 by Shn

nyxiah

nyxiah

Posts: 3,619 Adamant Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
Shn said :
In RSC, the viewable area was a 20x20 grid (400 tiles in your viewing area).



If we make realistic assumptions, like the floor “being scattered” means 30% of the entire player’s view being littered with Santa Hats, this is already 120x hats. If we also assume this is happening 5 times an hour in different popular locations around RS for an entire day, this is 14,400 Santa Hats made. If these are indeed being dropped in populated areas it’s safe to say virtually every single hat was picked up.

If we assume 30 locations are being populated 10 times an hour this is 864,000 Santa Hats. The question then becomes: are they all getting picked up?

You’ll note that you can tweak assumptions to fit your narrative pretty easily. I definitely wouldn’t put the idea that there are 100,000 hats in game out of the question. The trading volume is less because of the hoarding.


Thank you for sharing this useful information. I am sure that there are way less Santas in the game now since so many old players have left the game. I think 100k for 2009 is realistic. I do think the numbers dropped drastically throughout the years, as I lack heart mentioned 75k doesn't seem so much off in 2013. I just believe only 30-40% of these were active.
An inspiration to many, with a heart of gold. Be kind today, tomorrow and everyday!

03-Jul-2020 18:47:51

nyxiah

nyxiah

Posts: 3,619 Adamant Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
@ SHN

Yes, that is exactly what I thought too. I am pretty sure they used a command for a few items back then, I am unsure with the Halloween scythe tho'
An inspiration to many, with a heart of gold. Be kind today, tomorrow and everyday!

03-Jul-2020 18:50:32

4p
Dec Member 2007

4p

Posts: 967 Gold Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
Shn said :

I think the manner in which they were dropped was a JMod would log in and enter a command i.e. "::drop". This would generate the item in the vicinity and then create a local system message "System Update: Happy Easter!" or whatever was relevant for the drop. The fact a system message was being generated suggests that there was server side code triggered to assist with the drop; the JMod didn't have to manually drop the items. I do however, agree that a JMod would have to be the one issuing the command in game.


That makes sense, and further implies that there could never have been 100k+ Santa Hats in the first place. :)

Andrew would have had to spend his whole Christmas Day using his big shiny drop button!

03-Jul-2020 18:51:39

nyxiah

nyxiah

Posts: 3,619 Adamant Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
@ 4p

I think you should read what Shn mentioned earlier, the possibility could be up to 800k Santas.

Writing a command only takes a few seconds, so no, Andrew would not have had to spend his whole Christmas Day using his big shiny drop button :P
An inspiration to many, with a heart of gold. Be kind today, tomorrow and everyday!

03-Jul-2020 18:57:05

4p
Dec Member 2007

4p

Posts: 967 Gold Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
nyxiah said :
Shn said :
In RSC, the viewable area was a 20x20 grid (400 tiles in your viewing area).



If we make realistic assumptions, like the floor “being scattered” means 30% of the entire player’s view being littered with Santa Hats, this is already 120x hats. If we also assume this is happening 5 times an hour in different popular locations around RS for an entire day, this is 14,400 Santa Hats made. If these are indeed being dropped in populated areas it’s safe to say virtually every single hat was picked up.

If we assume 30 locations are being populated 10 times an hour this is 864,000 Santa Hats. The question then becomes: are they all getting picked up?

You’ll note that you can tweak assumptions to fit your narrative pretty easily. I definitely wouldn’t put the idea that there are 100,000 hats in game out of the question. The trading volume is less because of the hoarding.


Thank you for sharing this useful information. I am sure that there are way less Santas in the game now since so many old players have left the game. I think 100k for 2009 is realistic. I do think the numbers dropped drastically throughout the years, as I lack heart mentioned 75k doesn't seem so much off in 2013. I just believe only 30-40% of these were active.


Don't you think that makes it less realistic? Let's type it out a different way:

- The command scatters 120x Santa Hats
- The command is used in 30 locations (30 Jagex Mods?)
- The command is used 10 times an hour in those 30 locations (every 6 minutes)
= 864k Santa Hats

That's 30 Jagex Mods dropping Santas every 6 minutes, for 24hrs on Christmas day.

Scale that down to even 100k Santas and it's:
30 Jagex Mods dropping Santas every 52 minutes (rounded up)... on Christmas Day

Edit: Jagex had nowhere near 30 employees in 2002 (see YouTube documentary). And that's not even the biggest issue here!

03-Jul-2020 19:08:29 - Last edited on 03-Jul-2020 19:17:28 by 4p

Shn
Aug Member 2023

Shn

Posts: 406 Silver Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
4p said :


Don't you think that makes it less realistic? Let's type it out a different way:

- The command scatters 120x Santa Hats
- The command is used in 30 locations (30 Jagex Mods?)
- The command is used 10 times an hour in those 30 locations (every 6 minutes)
= 864k Santa Hats

That's 30 Jagex Mods dropping Santas every 6 minutes, for 24hrs on Christmas day.

Scale that down to even 100k Santas and it's:
30 Jagex Mods dropping Santas every 52 minutes (rounded up)... on Christmas Day

I don't believe Jagex had 30 employees in 2002,


You wouldn't need 30 employees to do this. You really just need a few Jmods logging in over the course of the day typing something as simple as "::drop" (the double semi-colon used to be a way to issue commands).

It would work by Andrew, Paul or maybe some other mod taking turns over the course of the day dropping items around in popular places where lots of players could access the rares. It would have been pretty easy to drop 20k-100k Santa hats in game.

As I mentioned, the fact that a system message would appear when an item is being dropped means that there was a command hardcoded into RSC that would handle the dropping. A mod wouldn't have to create 28x Santas and drop them individually. It's also very possible that no mods were even involved and there was a timer that dropped Santas at specific locations across RSC, in which case there wouldn't be the issue of mods having to log in and take turns spamming the drop command.

As a software engineer, I can say Andrew Gower is an extremely talented programmer. He would have no issue writing a "drop" command or a timer that could drop a bunch of rares.
Creator of RuneRares (no longer available). Been playing 15+ years.

03-Jul-2020 19:23:35 - Last edited on 03-Jul-2020 19:26:06 by Shn

nyxiah

nyxiah

Posts: 3,619 Adamant Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
@4p

There's one thing you seem to get wrong: you don't need 30 Jagex mods to type a command.

You don't need to stand on a location to do a command, it can be done within the system, in this case it seems to be coded to spawn on different locations, just as I assumed, and as it was done on OSRS.

In this case 800k Santas are possible, but there's most likely less, however 100k is still very realistic.

edit: I fully agree with Shn, this is most likely what they did.
An inspiration to many, with a heart of gold. Be kind today, tomorrow and everyday!

03-Jul-2020 19:25:33 - Last edited on 03-Jul-2020 19:27:43 by nyxiah

4p
Dec Member 2007

4p

Posts: 967 Gold Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
Shn said :
...If we make realistic assumptions, like the floor “being scattered” means 30% of the entire player’s view being littered with Santa Hats, this is already 120x hats. If we also assume this is happening 5 times an hour in different popular locations around RS for an entire day, this is 14,400 Santa Hats made. If these are indeed being dropped in populated areas it’s safe to say virtually every single hat was picked up.

If we assume 30 locations are being populated 10 times an hour this is 864,000 Santa Hats. The question then becomes: are they all getting picked up?...


The above quote is for use of the numbers only. To clarify, prevously when I said 'dropping' I meant using the '::drop' command which we have assumed.

Let's change the numbers to meet what we are now saying, and I'll be more specific:

- Andrew can do this from a console by typing '::drop' into the console
- One command populates 30 areas with 120x Santas
- The command is used 10 times an hour
=864k Santas in 24hrs

This would mean 1 Jagex Moderator would have to use the command once every 6 minutes to populate 30 areas with 120 Santas, over the course of 24 hours.

Again, scale it down to 100k Santas on release day:

1 Jagex Mod types '::drop' into a console every 52 minutes, for 24hrs, on Christmas Day. And then all of those Santas would have to be picked up and carried through to 2009, to make the volume of Santa Hats exactly 100k in 2009.

'20k - 100k Santas' does sound more realistic, although it's a broad range:

20k:
1 Jagex Mod types '::drop' into a console every 260 minutes (4.5hrs) over the course of 24hrs. (and enjoys the rest of their Christmas Day!)

50k:
1 Jagex Mod types '::drop' into a console every 104 minutes (1hr 45 minutes ish) over the course of 24hrs


Using the examples you're giving, I'm just trying to show how impossible it would be for there to be 100k Santas on release, let alone 2009. :)

03-Jul-2020 19:40:56

Quick find code: 17-18-536-66168267 Back to Top