Forums

On the Polled Quests

Quick find code: 16-17-2-66134546

Dilbert2001
Jun Member 2006

Dilbert2001

Posts: 30,176 Sapphire Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
Apparently, Violet is Blue 2, or better known as Violet is Green now, is coming despite of getting one of the lowest votes in the big Annual Runescape Survey.

https://www.reddit.com/r/runescape/comments/etyiwi/violet_is_green_is_the_next_quest/

Another illustration Jagex doesn't follow (and they don't need to follow) polled results blindly when it comes to developing their game content including quests.

26-Jan-2020 17:52:04

Mr Brushie

Mr Brushie

Posts: 1,161 Mithril Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
Dilbert2001 said :
Apparently, Violet is Blue 2, or better known as Violet is Green now, is coming despite of getting one of the lowest votes in the big Annual Runescape Survey.

https://www.reddit.com/r/runescape/comments/etyiwi/violet_is_green_is_the_next_quest/

Another illustration Jagex doesn't follow (and they don't need to follow) polled results blindly when it comes to developing their game content including quests.



So why the Christ does Jagex poll things if at the end of the day they aren't even going to go with the results?

Transparency, yeah mmhmm. Is it any wonder nobody believes anybody with a gold crown anymore?

27-Jan-2020 06:27:42

Dilbert2001
Jun Member 2006

Dilbert2001

Posts: 30,176 Sapphire Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
Mr Brushie said :
Dilbert2001 said :
Apparently, Violet is Blue 2, or better known as Violet is Green now, is coming despite of getting one of the lowest votes in the big Annual Runescape Survey.

https://www.reddit.com/r/runescape/comments/etyiwi/violet_is_green_is_the_next_quest/

Another illustration Jagex doesn't follow (and they don't need to follow) polled results blindly when it comes to developing their game content including quests.



So why the Christ does Jagex poll things if at the end of the day they aren't even going to go with the results?

Transparency, yeah mmhmm. Is it any wonder nobody believes anybody with a gold crown anymore?


They already explained in Runefest, it would be problematic if they just develop content solely based on poll results as in OSRS. They'll use survey/poll results as references only in RS3.

27-Jan-2020 16:02:41

Saint Benjy
Sep Member 2005

Saint Benjy

Posts: 1,990 Mithril Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
Dilbert2001 said :
Apparently, Violet is Blue 2, or better known as Violet is Green now, is coming despite of getting one of the lowest votes in the big Annual Runescape Survey.

https://www.reddit.com/r/runescape/comments/etyiwi/violet_is_green_is_the_next_quest/

Another illustration Jagex doesn't follow (and they don't need to follow) polled results blindly when it comes to developing their game content including quests.


This makes me suspect it was a low-hanging fruit. Lets just how it's a show, not tell kind of quest.

23-Feb-2020 07:00:00

Deltaslug

Deltaslug

Posts: 32,671 Sapphire Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
Mr Brushie said :
Dilbert2001 said :
Apparently, Violet is Blue 2, or better known as Violet is Green now, is coming despite of getting one of the lowest votes in the big Annual Runescape Survey.

https://www.reddit.com/r/runescape/comments/etyiwi/violet_is_green_is_the_next_quest/

Another illustration Jagex doesn't follow (and they don't need to follow) polled results blindly when it comes to developing their game content including quests.



So why the Christ does Jagex poll things if at the end of the day they aren't even going to go with the results?

Transparency, yeah mmhmm. Is it any wonder nobody believes anybody with a gold crown anymore?


Sometimes, things get polled not so much as to see it get dev'd, but to see where it might stand with the community.
Just because a dev thinks the idea could be funny or technically useful, doesn't mean that the community as whole thinks so. For example: they could have had 3 ideas for a Land of Snow themed quest, and instead of a Violet focused sequel, she now has a small cameo in it or her part makes up a small section of the overall quest.

Sometimes, a weak concept could also be held onto to either be reworked/rewritten later ... or be rolled into another concept.

Sometimes, the idea would still come out ... just instead of it being say a Fate of the Gods type quest in terms of production, they instead opt to scale it down to the scope of a bottle quest.

23-Feb-2020 19:56:39 - Last edited on 23-Feb-2020 20:00:27 by Deltaslug

Saint Benjy
Sep Member 2005

Saint Benjy

Posts: 1,990 Mithril Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
Deltaslug said :

Sometimes, things get polled not so much as to see it get dev'd, but to see where it might stand with the community.
Just because a dev thinks the idea could be funny or technically useful, doesn't mean that the community as whole thinks so. For example: they could have had 3 ideas for a Land of Snow themed quest, and instead of a Violet focused sequel, she now has a small cameo in it or her part makes up a small section of the overall quest.

Sometimes, a weak concept could also be held onto to either be reworked/rewritten later ... or be rolled into another concept.

Sometimes, the idea would still come out ... just instead of it being say a Fate of the Gods type quest in terms of production, they instead opt to scale it down to the scope of a bottle quest.


It's possible they're also looking for a higher percentage, something 75+% like OSRS lol :P

15-Apr-2020 07:02:22

GhostlyBard

GhostlyBard

Posts: 4,332 Adamant Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
It’s like the 2015 polling for expansions in the end it didn’t really matter, 5 years later we have the winner (the arc) & Menaphos plus Anachronia, only one we’re technically missing is underwater city. But that kind of got some attention with the pirate quest and elite dungeons.

Seemingly an overarching plan for Rs is already in place and it has been for a while.

Bad at analogies but think of it as Mod Osbourne steering the ship through a field of icebergs, with a bunch of little speedboats (other devs) getting to make excursions (game content) occasionally they’ll find survivors on the icebergs (players) who in exchange for being saved (playing new content) offer guidance (feedback) which is some times actioned upon, and some times lost as the players fall overboard.

Hopefully Dave can navigate a safe
passage
and not sink the ship. :P

Also yay for a Violet is blue sequel. :D
Also also left a not overly subtle hint for a quest I’d love to still happen but in all likelihood isn’t going to.
Check out Thieves guild layout redesign. Happy ‘scaping

15-Apr-2020 12:07:30 - Last edited on 15-Apr-2020 13:35:54 by GhostlyBard

Jeremy Cheng
Aug Member 2013

Jeremy Cheng

Posts: 25,647 Sapphire Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
[66.5%] Desert Treasure 2

1) Yes great! I'd love for RS3 to do DT2 before OSRS.

[65.7%] Temple at Sennisten 2

2) No need with t99 prayers.

[65.1%] Dragon Slayer 2

3) How would they do this with dragonkin on our side?

---------------------------------
[64.4%] Skillcape Quest

4) Pointless. No thanks.

[61.6%] Origins of Zaros

5) We already know this.

[61.6%] Back to the God Wars

6) Already happening with GWD3.

[61.2%] White Knight Finale

7) Storyline was already completed.

[61.0%] Elf Storyline

8) Again, storyline was already completed.

[60.7%] Barrows-Search for Death

9) Again, storyline was already completed.

[59.7%] Menaphos Finale

10) Still waiting for amascut to be defeated yes.

[57.0%] Who is the Raptor

11) He's an Elder God disguised /thread.

[53.4%] Return of King Valliance

12) This was already an event.

[53.0%] Riders of the Apocalypse

13) They're around.

[52.7%] One of a Kind 2

14) I'd like to bring back V yes.

[51.6%] Pilgrimage of Guthix

15) Fake news, never happening and never heard of.

[51.4%] Vampyre Storyline

16) Vanescula is already in archaeology

[51.2%] Araxxor Quest

17) I don't want quests requiring bosskills of bosses I can't kill

[50.2%] Breaking History

18) Was never confirmed

[50.0%] Death of Wise Old Man

19) He already died in osrs

[50.0%] Monkey Madness 2

20) Don't waste Glough the same way osrs did

-----------------------------------

[43.7%] Sons of V

21) Where was it revealed V has kids?

[39.6%] Thok Quest

22) if it introduces Chaotic floors sure.

[35.2%] Violet is Blue 2

23) Oh god please let this never happen. had a tough time with the snowballs

15-Apr-2020 12:15:17 - Last edited on 15-Apr-2020 12:17:22 by Jeremy Cheng

Quick find code: 16-17-2-66134546 Back to Top