Forums
Clan Score: Clan Ratings
Quick find code: 86-87-339-65866109
Jamandy52
said
:
concerning fraud As I've said multiple times now, I am not in charge of preventing fraud. That said, because of the way the form is set up, you are required to give your display name (for reference). If your scenario were a case of fraud, I'd imagine that our staff who check this would verify if the people whose usernames were used were actually the ones writing the reviews.
Jamandy52 said :
2. Concerning fairness Ideally, it would be best if the person writing a review of their clan were somewhat knowledgeable of that clan to begin with. I also think it'd be commonsense to ask someone else in the clan if you're unsure of an answer.
Concerning "encouraging" people to review the clan, because usernames are required, I'd assume our staff would check if those people were all from the same clan and make a determination off of that.
Jamandy52 said :
3. One of your questions, reads as follows: This was a typo and has been corrected, as has the "dau" typo
concerning fraud As I've said multiple times now, I am not in charge of preventing fraud. That said, because of the way the form is set up, you are required to give your display name (for reference). If your scenario were a case of fraud, I'd imagine that our staff who check this would verify if the people whose usernames were used were actually the ones writing the reviews.
Jamandy52 said :
2. Concerning fairness Ideally, it would be best if the person writing a review of their clan were somewhat knowledgeable of that clan to begin with. I also think it'd be commonsense to ask someone else in the clan if you're unsure of an answer.
Concerning "encouraging" people to review the clan, because usernames are required, I'd assume our staff would check if those people were all from the same clan and make a determination off of that.
Jamandy52 said :
3. One of your questions, reads as follows: This was a typo and has been corrected, as has the "dau" typo
04-Jan-2017 01:51:50
Original message details are unavailable.
Ideally, it would be best if the person writing a review of their clan were somewhat knowledgeable of that clan to begin with. I also think it'd be commonsense to ask someone else in the clan if you're unsure of an answer.
Concerning "encouraging" people to review the clan, because usernames are required, I'd assume our staff would check if those people were all from the same clan and make a determination off of that.
And then comes the question that, why wouldn't people in a clan want to review that clan?
And then on the other side of the coin, if you have left a clan you review but changed your name, the prior clan may not have tracked name changes and may not be able to validate that account, even though it would be a legitimate review.
--
Also with all the multitudes of questions regarding legitimacy concerns, posed by both myself and others, you may want to ask whoever is in charge to answer these questions for us rther than a blanket state of 'not my department so i have no idea'. 23 200ms. Founder of Jamandy52 skilling clan. Favorite skill: Construction. Love skilling. Love minigames.
Working on 200m Divination atm. PM for effigies assists, and for tips when skilling. World 70.
Ideally, it would be best if the person writing a review of their clan were somewhat knowledgeable of that clan to begin with. I also think it'd be commonsense to ask someone else in the clan if you're unsure of an answer.
Concerning "encouraging" people to review the clan, because usernames are required, I'd assume our staff would check if those people were all from the same clan and make a determination off of that.
And then comes the question that, why wouldn't people in a clan want to review that clan?
And then on the other side of the coin, if you have left a clan you review but changed your name, the prior clan may not have tracked name changes and may not be able to validate that account, even though it would be a legitimate review.
--
Also with all the multitudes of questions regarding legitimacy concerns, posed by both myself and others, you may want to ask whoever is in charge to answer these questions for us rther than a blanket state of 'not my department so i have no idea'. 23 200ms. Founder of Jamandy52 skilling clan. Favorite skill: Construction. Love skilling. Love minigames.
Working on 200m Divination atm. PM for effigies assists, and for tips when skilling. World 70.
04-Jan-2017 02:02:47 - Last edited on 04-Jan-2017 02:05:53 by Jamandy52
Jamandy52
said
:
And then comes the question that, why wouldn't people in a clan want to review that clan?
Exactly, which actually contradicts a prior concern by Subzero, who said the survey felt biased against clans.
Jamandy52 said :
And then on the other side of the coin, if you have left a clan you review but changed your name, the prior clan may not have tracked name changes and may not be able to validate that account, even though it would be a legitimate review. Again, "not my department," but I do know services such as Runeclan are capable of tracking username changes and changes in clans.
Jamandy52 said :
Also with all the multitudes of questions regarding legitimacy concerns, posed by both myself and others, you may want to ask whoever is in charge to answer these questions for us rther than a blanket state of 'not my department so i have no idea'. I will gather a list of concerns from this thread and have someone reply to them, with me posting his responses here.
And then comes the question that, why wouldn't people in a clan want to review that clan?
Exactly, which actually contradicts a prior concern by Subzero, who said the survey felt biased against clans.
Jamandy52 said :
And then on the other side of the coin, if you have left a clan you review but changed your name, the prior clan may not have tracked name changes and may not be able to validate that account, even though it would be a legitimate review. Again, "not my department," but I do know services such as Runeclan are capable of tracking username changes and changes in clans.
Jamandy52 said :
Also with all the multitudes of questions regarding legitimacy concerns, posed by both myself and others, you may want to ask whoever is in charge to answer these questions for us rther than a blanket state of 'not my department so i have no idea'. I will gather a list of concerns from this thread and have someone reply to them, with me posting his responses here.
04-Jan-2017 02:18:31 - Last edited on 04-Jan-2017 02:19:13 by SpectreGh0st
SpectreGh0st
said
:
Jamandy52 said :
And then comes the question that, why wouldn't people in a clan want to review that clan?
Exactly, which actually contradicts a prior concern by Subzero, who said the survey felt biased against clans.
Jamandy52 said :
And then on the other side of the coin, if you have left a clan you review but changed your name, the prior clan may not have tracked name changes and may not be able to validate that account, even though it would be a legitimate review. Again, "not my department," but I do know services such as Runeclan are capable of tracking username changes and changes in clans.
Jamandy52 said :
Also with all the multitudes of questions regarding legitimacy concerns, posed by both myself and others, you may want to ask whoever is in charge to answer these questions for us rther than a blanket state of 'not my department so i have no idea'. I will gather a list of concerns from this thread and have someone reply to them, with me posting his responses here.
Cool thanks
23 200ms. Founder of Jamandy52 skilling clan. Favorite skill: Construction. Love skilling. Love minigames.
Working on 200m Divination atm. PM for effigies assists, and for tips when skilling. World 70.
Jamandy52 said :
And then comes the question that, why wouldn't people in a clan want to review that clan?
Exactly, which actually contradicts a prior concern by Subzero, who said the survey felt biased against clans.
Jamandy52 said :
And then on the other side of the coin, if you have left a clan you review but changed your name, the prior clan may not have tracked name changes and may not be able to validate that account, even though it would be a legitimate review. Again, "not my department," but I do know services such as Runeclan are capable of tracking username changes and changes in clans.
Jamandy52 said :
Also with all the multitudes of questions regarding legitimacy concerns, posed by both myself and others, you may want to ask whoever is in charge to answer these questions for us rther than a blanket state of 'not my department so i have no idea'. I will gather a list of concerns from this thread and have someone reply to them, with me posting his responses here.
Cool thanks
23 200ms. Founder of Jamandy52 skilling clan. Favorite skill: Construction. Love skilling. Love minigames.
Working on 200m Divination atm. PM for effigies assists, and for tips when skilling. World 70.
04-Jan-2017 02:37:16
Quick find code: 86-87-339-65866109 Back to Top