The fire is indeed out. Smoke bellows from your eyelids, while the feint clicking of arcing can be heard beneath. You are still holding your flaming board while munching on cookies.
You throw the baking soda atop the flaming board. Mysteriously, warm carbonated soda seems to seep from the flames. Your eyes are still shut by your lids, and you're currently wielding a sticky soda seeping flaming board while munching cookies.