Forums

The Incredibly Gifted Authors

Quick find code: 49-50-561-60783913

A White Wolf

A White Wolf

Posts: 8,377 Rune Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
Azigarath, I'm working 40+ hours a week at the moment, so please be patient and I'll get around to your application when I can. Thanks in advance.
***
Malevolent:
"This literally almost made me gag. And I love steak. I am a happy carnivore."
I'm not a vegetarian, but I don't enjoy eating meat either. So I'm glad I made the almighty Wolf gag, I was told it wasn't possible.

***
Allow me to emphasize for clarity - "[...]ALMOST MADE ME GAG.[...]
[...]almost made me gag[...] =/= [...]made the almighty Wolf gag[...]
Sorry hotshot. Nice attempt though, and points for effort.

21-May-2010 02:36:25

A White Wolf

A White Wolf

Posts: 8,377 Rune Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
Woopsies, yes, apparently I do need a reminder.
I'd totally forgotten, sorry. I'm a bad guild leader. Also, the forum separation updates basically halted any interest I still had in the forums at all. I haven't posted in 3 weeks.
I'm really sorry about the wait, I'll review your application now.

09-Jun-2010 00:59:02

A White Wolf

A White Wolf

Posts: 8,377 Rune Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
"And the gallant crusaders reached the ancient walls of Byzantium, the last remnants of the Roman Empire."
This is a really bad way to begin a story. Firstly, as 'and' is a conjunction, it isn't exactly grammatical to begin a sentence with it. Furthermore, while some authors use it stylistically to carry action or something from preceding passages, you have nothing written before it to carry though.
It feels disjointed.
"Interested in seeing the remnants of the Roman Empire, many of the crusaders, from archers to knights, explored here and there, drinking from fountains, or wishing into them."
SO MANY COMMAS. O_O At least they're grammatical. I would recommend trying to avoid passages like this, as a less-skilled reader might be confused.
"In the golden city of sweet-smelling flowers and graceful nobility, such a pleasant world was beyond the dreams of the European crusaders."
I like the description in this sentence, but apart from this, description is very sparse. I can't really picture either the city or the knights entering it.
"One of the knights, the average chivalrous knight whom has been through many battles, spotted a nice pair of shoes on the counter."
Firstly, "whom" is used incorrectly. "Whom" functions only as an objective-tense pronoun, meaning it can function as the object or object of a preposition in a sentence. (Think similarly to how "he" and "him" work.)
For instance, "From whom was this gift?" or "He did what with whom?"
Also, the fact that the knight had seen many battles is extraneous. It doesn't matter to the current situation. Use physical descriptors to help your reader visualize the current scene.

09-Jun-2010 00:59:42 - Last edited on 09-Jun-2010 01:55:13 by A White Wolf

A White Wolf

A White Wolf

Posts: 8,377 Rune Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
"The knight put down a cascade of lovely gold, silver and copper coins onto the counter, but to the merchant's surprise, the knight only pushed a few of them toward the merchant, as if to say, 'this is how much I will pay.'"
Try to keep personal exchanges realistic; it helps believability. No one in their right mind ever shows off how much money they have only to then try to bargain. It's counter-productive; they'll know you have more money left and will be unwilling to cut a deal. Little things like this go a long way to making a story believable and entertaining.
"For a few minutes, the knight and merchant were taking turns using their fingers to drag money side to side, and this made a few other knights chuckle form the sight."
***
"The knight bargaining over the pair of shoes got rather irritated, and by this time, some other crusaders were actually chuckling from the sight."
We already know that the sight was humorous from the first description; reiteration merely overemphasizes and wears a reader out. Try to re-read and consolidate passages that have redundancy.
"The knight then got angry and took back ass his coins, then counted them out (though even in this case his ability was limited) about four or five coins, just two silver and the rest copper, and upon confirming that this was a reasonable sum, he handed them to the merchant as a final offer."
Proofread, proofread, proofread. Especially when you make typos that are accidentally profanity. As a general rule of thumb, also, parentheses have very little place in prose writing; a semicolon, colon, or dash much more attractively denotes a pause in thought.
FINAL SUMMARY:
The entire story felt very rushed, in my opinion. While overall spelling, grammar, and punctuation were't bad at all, the near-complete lack of Shown description made for a very dry read.
If you elaborate more, with the intent of immersing your reader, your writing will improve drastically.

09-Jun-2010 01:00:02 - Last edited on 09-Jun-2010 02:04:19 by A White Wolf

A White Wolf

A White Wolf

Posts: 8,377 Rune Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
Watch out for passive voice writing as well. Passive versus active voice plays an enormous role in how engaging and exciting a particular read is.
Passive voice is describing an action that occurred, while active depicts an action being performed.
Examples:
Passive = "There is a man walking a dog."
Active = "The man is walking the dog."
Overall, I think if you concentrate on improving "Shown" description vs. "Told" description, as well as work on making sure passive voice isn't slipping in, you'll see a very great improvement in your writing.
You are not accepted to TIGA, Azigarath. Thank you for applying though, and I hope you continue improving and continue writing here in the forums. (and forgive me for how long this review took to get to you.)

09-Jun-2010 02:08:50

Quick find code: 49-50-561-60783913 Back to Top