Forums

Wrath of the Dark Empire

Quick find code: 49-50-536-60692025

Azigarath

Azigarath

Posts: 9,271 Rune Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
Ah, your debut of the Stories Forum. I did read on Tarot that your earlier story would not be worth reading, though it is also important to reflect upon earlier works for personal learning. I have learned much from rereading my own early stories, seeing many issues that needed fixing and adjustment.

Well, the story's introduction is fairly clichéd, unsurprisingly, it's not like one should expect another's first story to have the expanse of Tolkien or Stephen King or what have you. So, there is an evil force that wants to conquer the world, spreading its darkness, as it has nothing better to do I suppose.

"Dark soldiers flocked onto the roof of Lumbridge Castle,"
How did they get up there? I'm assuming that they stormed the courtyard, forced the entrance open, and took the castle that way.

"From behind, a dark blade cut into the Leader’s back; he gurgled, and blood flew from his jaw."
If he wore the armour of a knight, there is no way to cut through the armour. And how did someone managed to sneak up on him like that?

So far, there is a lack of description. For instance, I do not know what the warriors are wearing, what kind of armour they have, how they are fighting, or what type of sword they are wielding. Do they wield traditional cut and thrust swords, longswords, godenaks, falchions, messers, smallswords, kords, sabres, estocs - you get the point. You also overuse the word dark, though I suppose it doesn't really matter now, but I'll comment as if I read this two years ago.

On Chapter 1, the transformation of the castle seems to have immediate. Although not mentioned, it does feel like the changes occurred overnight.

Hey, I recall reading this story I think two years ago-ish, though it seems that I did not finish it.

01-Jan-2013 21:32:39

Azigarath

Azigarath

Posts: 9,271 Rune Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
"“Good!” Yahi cackled for a little while, stroking and whispering to her statues."
Laughter after acknowledgment of an enemy's end is somewhat overused, though it is kinda funny how she then strokes her statues, suggesting that Yahi is, well, not only evil, but childish as well.

"“We haven’t found the bodies of Generals Croce and Cook, but they wore no armour, so they were probably sliced to pieces.”"
Why would generals not wear armour? 0.o

The generals have silly names :/

Well, the numbers are very small. For example, Al Kharid, the Empire of Sand, is besieged by two hundred soldiers. Doesn't sound much of an empire if it only takes two hundred people to destroy it.

"One arrow flew over a roof, and landed amidst the Dark Army, hitting one soldier in the throat."
Ouch, unlucky, though the arch of an arrow firing over a roof would have probably struck him in the forehead assuming he isn't wearing a helm, though I'd imagine the arrow would be seen, and it'd take more than a minute for someone to die by this means. During that one minute, no one offered to help him?

"They appeared from behind trees and buildings. They appeared on rooftops and the treetops."
How did they manage to do that?

"He and Rois battled for hours at a time."
Impossible, very rarely can a swordsman fight for more than six minutes.

Read through chapters 4, 5, 6, 7 and 8, and it's here that there is visible improvement overall, though some characters feel unrealistic. For example, a soldier has a bad dream, so his sarge says he's sorry, doesn't feel like military. Later, when Tigo and Senshio meet, they shake hands and become friends, so positive emotion happens very quickly amidst the spreading evil. Yahi's behaviour is subject to silliness, though I'm assuming it was intentional.

And English offers a review about mechanics. Nice to see, so I won't bother with my own issues on that.

Oh? Over already? The last few pages of the thread have no story.

01-Jan-2013 21:33:07

Azigarath

Azigarath

Posts: 9,271 Rune Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
Well, at least I finished this on New Year's Day. I do not wish to repeat English's posts too much, though you do have storytelling and such things present throughout the story. Unfortunately, I do not seem to have had many compliments upon reading, though it was only the first half of the story that needed improvement.

Although I do not focus much on mechanical things in literature, though you do overuse "silence" and "dark". I especially focus on realism (about Medieval combat), so I suppose this is one thing that I feel needs improvement. For starters, you mention the combat, but it is not described much. I know nothing of armour, weapons, and utilisation of such equipment. I know that there seems to be archers and infantry out of two hundred soldiers for the Dark Army. Since the story isn't finished, I'll assume my opinion will be worthwhile.

Here are some links to videos that will greatly expand ideas for realistic, historic combat, though the title is also underneath the link; by watching historic fighting, you can implement it with some fiction and have a really good time on combat.

Also, due to the annoying censor, there will be little issues, so you can also just put the title on the command line of YouTube and select the according upload. Note that there are different rules of combat if you are in plate or mail armour, or unarmoured. Thus, the videos that feature plate-armoured presenters are doing their things according to what you do while in plate armour.

Although these videos are quite a stretch to go through, I’d recommend watching them carefully if you plan on developing the combat of your story. If not, then never mind.

http://***.youtube.***/watch?v=TtNZQBc4RpE&feature=related
Longsword Techniques - Receiving Strikes on Flat

http://***.youtube.***/watch?v=ov_iVrHy4_A
CAS Hanwei - 2010 Blade show - John Clements Historical European Swordsmanship

01-Jan-2013 21:33:36

Azigarath

Azigarath

Posts: 9,271 Rune Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
http://***.youtube.***/watch?v=7Ijy8Ky_vrI&feature=related
15th Century fighting demonstration

http://***.youtube.***/watch?v=bWISsk0cy74&feature=fvwp&NR=1
Messer Techniques from Talhoffer

http://***.youtube.***/watch?v=-TzdtyMC7ek&feature=related
Fencing with five different medieval weapons

http://***.youtube.***/watch?v=wR7RlwSGj50&feature=related
Rediscovering the Chinese Long Sword

http://***.youtube.***/watch?v=xFiIDl_mt2c&feature=related
Sword Fighting As It Was For the Vikings

****://***.youtube.***/watch?v=Kj4Ng6DB***&feature=related
Fechten mit dem langen Schwert

http://***.youtube.***/watch?v=Iwt0Rub8Iic&feature=related
Salut, walka na szable husarskie

http://***.youtube.***/watch?v=dkhpqAGdZPc&feature=related
Sword & Shield Fighting (Roland - Hammaborg) [fixed audio]

http://***.youtube.***/watch?v=Fv-Vut0xb9Y&feature=related
hammaborg halbs**wert gladiatoria 13r + 13 v

http://***.youtube.***/watch?v=1S_Q3CGqZmg&feature=related
Gladiatoria : Part 1/6 : Swordfight in Armour : Hammaborg

http://***.youtube.***/watch?v=5hlIUrd7d1Q&feature=related
Le combat en armure au XVe siècle

http://***.youtube.***/watch?v=YPKrAfww79U&feature=related
Henry VIII's foot combat armour for the Field of Cloth of Gold tournament in 1520

http://***.youtube.***/watch?v=G4k-vjdeZO4&feature=related
SwArta Harnischfechten

http://***.youtube.***/watch?v=2ea5-nMpJL0
Harnischfechten sparring demonstration

http://***.youtube.***/watch?v=kl-ec6Ub7FM
Testing Swords Against Riveted Mail Armor

Unarmed combat

http://***.youtube.***/watch?v=7rp2***1vRo&feature=relmfu
SwArta - Ringkunst In Ernst

http://***.youtube.***/watch?v=lvkPLvoH1vI&feature=related
Twirch Ringen (Updated)

Bows and Crossbows

http://***.youtube.***/watch?v=gaz9MfxVDp0
Archery: The Revival Of Ottoman Archery Techniques

http://***.youtube.***/watch?v=KCE40J93m5c
Breastplate Vs Warbows

****://***.youtube.***/watch?v=D3997HZuWjk
Longbow vs Plate Armour

01-Jan-2013 21:34:33

Azigarath

Azigarath

Posts: 9,271 Rune Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
http://***.youtube.***/watch?v=jrOIQRn***c&feature=related
The Japanese Bow - Weapon of the Samurai - Ancient Civilizations

http://***.youtube.***/watch?v=76mbOMFjlu0&feature=related
15th century crossbow

Misc.

http://***.youtube.***/watch?v=B95By9w2MWA
How not to charge a shield wall

http://***.youtube.***/watch?v=jAAFczOyLVo&feature=related
Military Designs from Talhoffer's Medieval Combat Manual

http://***.youtube.***/watch?v=5Hy_A9vjp_s
Welt der Wunder - Katana vs. Schwert - Teil 2
(Skip to 5:50)

http://***.youtube.***/watch?v=_hfLZozBVpM
Two Handed Great Sword

http://***.youtube.***/watch?v=hjV7lYP6hRw&feature=relmfu
Weapon Masters- Atlatl vs. Steel Armor

Series (some are of multiple parts) and presentations, though these are wholly optional

http://***.youtube.***/watch?v=EL3-GpZQdS4&feature=related
Warriors - Spartan Vengeance - Part 1

http://***.youtube.***/watch?v=paZBkbKM77g&feature=related
Warriros Viking - Terror 1/5

http://***.youtube.***/watch?v=rubruP9p4i8&feature=related
The last crusaders

http://***.youtube.***/watch?v=NqC_squo6X4&feature=related
How to Mount a Horse in Armor and Other Chivalric Problems

01-Jan-2013 21:34:52

Crocefisso

Crocefisso

Posts: 1,385 Mithril Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
I'm very grateful for your extensive feedback****, I just fear that it's come about three and a half years too late - I gave up this story after about a month, in May 2010, and don't really intend to return to it. Nevertheless, I will take your detailed points into consideration should I ever write something even vaguely similar again.

11-Sep-2013 20:43:57

Quick find code: 49-50-536-60692025 Back to Top