Actually, I’m not good at debating either. But I decided to skip to your fifth story, which has length I like, so it should be a good read regardless if I enjoy it or not. I am guessing it’s ok the skip World in Flames 2 for now. I will also chop down the amount of feedback, commentary and criticism as best I can, but your story at first glance exceeds 200 posts, so I’m not sure how well I can do that.
So I begin with bios, a similar formula your first story has. I have also used the name Raphael in my own stories. His sword is somewhat flawed; gold is too soft and too heavy to be useful in practical situations. Perhaps you meant the hilt was gilded? Holding a one-handed sword with the blade down is not sensible, however, it is good for tackling a wall of pikes. Chinese swordsmen sometimes held their swords with the blade downward as to better deflect pikes and spears while charging. Raphael is revealed to have lost his family, though it is a bit odd that his mother disappeared, wouldn’t his father be there during birth? A fifteen year-old boy as a member of a council? That’s a bit young, but oh well.
Governanti reminds me of illuminati.
“Elena may use a Steel Longsword to defend herself from anyone attacking her from close range.”
Makes sense, but this is kinda obvious. :/
A bow made of strong wood is good, but a bow made of flexible wood is even better. The idea of Elena rarely missing a shot since childhood is even beyond realism, I’ve been practising with the bow since late childhood and I still miss most of the time.
“He wields a 29 inch long sword made of silver known as Silver's End.”
Twenty-nine inches is not a longsword, there are arming swords longer than that. A longsword would be at least forty inches. Silver is not a good metal for anything longer than a knife blade, it is almost as soft as gold.
11-Jun-2013 06:02:01