Forums

~` Illusions `~

Quick find code: 49-50-309-58156467

CaptChekaka

CaptChekaka

Posts: 35,595 Sapphire Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
I have, but it's been about a year since I've finished one. The last, and only, was Disruption around 73 posts. I'm wanting to finish one of better length. :P

I think this'll be my creative writing class goal. I dunno.

-- Chek

31-Dec-2008 17:03:44

[#WIK7YQF0Z]

[#WIK7YQF0Z]

Posts: 2,189 Mithril Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
Only mistakes I could find, really. Correct me if I'm wrong.


-Page 6, post 1-

This, however, is not mentioning the finely polished shoes that were bought for him.

>>> I don’t know if I’m right, but shouldn’t “finely polished” be hyphenated? Correct me if I’m wrong.

-Page 6, post1-

“Well, here's what we have so far,” Landon murmured as they stepped onto the road. >>“We’re here, at the bank.”<< Landon pointed to a direction on the map he had bought earlier. “The courtyard is in the direct center of the city, so we’ve already been there. North of it is the castle, obviously, while south of it is that shop we bought your sword at.” The stout man stopped again, motioning towards the black weapon. >>“West of the courtyard is where we are: the bank.”<<

>>>Unless you meant to mention the bank twice, I suggest you get rid of either one of the bank references in Landon’s dialogue.

-Page 6, post1-

“West of the courtyard is where we are: the bank.” We can either travel further down this path and out of the city, or we can cut straight through and not have to circle the entire perimeter. I think the latter would be best, correct?”

>>> You need to get rid of the quotation mark after ‘bank’ if you’re going to continue the dialogue.

--

Hmmm. Interesting adds.

31-Dec-2008 17:55:35

Doom 5500

Doom 5500

Posts: 3,162 Adamant Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
Right then. I've read the first chapter, and I noted what you said about this being cliché, so I won't mention that. I'm sorry if this comes off like a review, but I generally don't comment and something "It's good!" probably isn't very gratifying. So, um, here we go...

- - -

The prologue was very good, and I especially enjoyed the personification you used. The first real thing I noticed was on the first chapter:

"King Rezod sat idly in his chair, twisting a small chain, sivler in color, around his arm."

There's nothing explicity wrong, but it'a a bit wordy; how about : "...twisting a small silver chain around his arm..."

"Rezod’s brown hair, short in length..."

It's the same thing here. You seem a bit over-concerned with description. This is just my opinion, but in phrases such as this:

"He then lifted his hand, covered with a white glove..."

The bit about the glove just weighs the sentence down.

"...and his tattered clothes were obvious..."

That makes it sound like the clothes themselves are obvious.

“Set him atop my horse. I think that he, of course, is but a mercenary and has no issue with me as a man, or a soldier. If he wishes to continue his mission, then we shall let him; he and I will duel. However, if he wishes to cast aside such a task, then it will be us he will come to.”

Pretty good reasoning there. I like this character.

- - -

Overall, I really like what I've read so far. The only true problems were the excess description and your infatuation with commas.

I'll read the rest of it soon, ;)

31-Dec-2008 22:06:33

CaptChekaka

CaptChekaka

Posts: 35,595 Sapphire Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
Chuk - No idea, really. Longer than Disruption, though.

Homzy - Thanks. ^_^

Doom - Yeah, description is an incredible wall for me in my work. I always seem to go overboard quite a bit. :P Thanks for pointing those out, though: I'll get on them immediately.

-- Chek

31-Dec-2008 22:39:01

Quick find code: 49-50-309-58156467 Back to Top