Forums

DEATH

Quick find code: 49-50-255-58364524

Cozmic

Cozmic

Posts: 16,435 Opal Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
==========

---You examine the warrior, experimenting his skills in battle.

Which one? Earlier you mentioned multiple ones. I suggest either changing it so he sees one, or saying he walks up to a particular one.

==========

---He whips out his crude bronze sword, the golden hilt becoming a sideways glance.

Becoming a sideways glance? What?

==========

---“He slashed this way and that,[...]”

You are writing present tense, no?

==========

---Quick as lightning, he whips out a bow and arrow, and deposits the sword and shield in his inventory

I dislike the concept of “In his inventory”, could you at least say “Slung over his back”?

==========

He starts to rapidly fire, looking a bit nervous. You observe that he is obviously not skilled in the art of range

Perhaps better to delete the second sentence and put:

“He starts to rapidly fire in a rather sloppy, and inexperienced manner, a nervous look on his face.”

Do not tell the reader – show them.

==========

---He takes out two rune stones, one appeared to be an air rune, and you are just able to make out the symbol on the mind rune.

Comma splice = bad.

Replace the first comma with a semicolon.

==========

---The runes crumble to the floor, as he starts to revolve the swirling air ball in his hands.

I don’t think the comma is needed. Perhaps it should be combined with the pervious sentence via a semicolon for flow.

==========

---He thrusts his hands out, and the swirling air mass collides with the goblin, sending the creature tumbling over, smashing his head against a house.

It has so many actions it sounds unnatural. I suggest you break up into multiple sentences.

==========

---His head lolls to the side, and it finally falls forward.

He was decapitated? I think you meant ‘and HE finally falls forward’.

==========

---[...]and the warrior walked over to affirm[...]

He ‘walked’? Change it to present tense.

“He walks”

==========

05-Mar-2009 16:10:11

Cozmic

Cozmic

Posts: 16,435 Opal Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
==========

He approved so, and looted the goblin of a few coins and his chain mail.

you used ‘lootED’.

You are writing present tense... Z0mg...

==========

---[...]goblin mail, but it clearly didn't fit.

I’ll give you three guesses what wrong...

...

... No, it’s not a comma splice...

...

FINALLY! You got it right, you used *didn’t* again... PAST TENSE!

I suggest you change to “Doesn’t”

==========

The goblin strikes him, and he doubles over, his eyes rolling back in his head.

Comma splice. Use a semicolon.

==========

05-Mar-2009 16:10:27

Cozmic

Cozmic

Posts: 16,435 Opal Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
~~~~~~~~~~ Chapter 1.2 ~~~~~~~~~~

==========

---[...]observing the bright sunshine shining upon the magnificent castle.


I suggest you change shining; it sounds a bit repetitive having ‘sunSHINE’ beside ‘shining’.

==========

---Across from you are the fountains of Lumbridge, spraying water into the air like a magnificent geyser.

Like magnificent gyser*S*. You have to you the plural when speaking of multiple fountains.

==========

---I don’t think I like the next few sentences. You imply that the grand exchange is the only thing they are talking about – while in the pervious sentence you say they talka bout “Many things”.

==========

---“Can you help me?” asked a level 24 player, walking up to a level 109.

The same mistake many noob stories make – Using combat levels just seems... a bad way of judging them, perhaps you could describe their equipment, which would give a clue to their levels?

==========

---You think to yourself, “I should be doing that right now. No! What am I thinking? I must…. No! What is wrong with me?! Please… Oh Saradomin! Help me!”

When thinking, use ‘ symbols around the text, not quotation marks. What you wrote implies talking.

==========

---A deep voice echoed inside your head, with a dark, raspy tone to it.

Echoed? Change it to present tense.

==========

---"Stop! Don’t repeat that word in my presence or I’ll kill you!”

Rather blunt. Perhaps something like, “Or I will rend your flesh like butter and decapitate your limbs with fire!”

==========

---Zamorak thundered inside your head,[...]

PAST TENSE! The second half also has it – keep the tense the same.

==========

05-Mar-2009 16:42:35 - Last edited on 05-Mar-2009 16:43:07 by Cozmic

Cozmic

Cozmic

Posts: 16,435 Opal Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
==========

In the second paragraph of post 8, you use “You start” at the beginning of several sentences – I suggest changing one of them.

==========

---You start to shut down, everything becoming a blur before your eyes. Your skin becomes pale white, and you start to roll on the floor. You let out one final scream, your eyes close, and you fall into darkness.

I suggest you put something like a “---“ “~~~” or “* * *” here to signify a lapse of time, or a change of scene.

==========

---Deep inside, although you might not want to admit it, is a pleading voice that wants to worship me, something that screams out inside you, but you silence it every time.

Zamorak must be an illiterate oaf – he comma spliced while talking. Put a semicolon after ‘me’.

==========

---The main two factors would be your Defense level,[...]

No... Zamorak talking about defense levels? BAH! First of all, it would be more logical for it to be his magic level, as magic contributes to 80ish percent of your magic defense in the game itself. Otherwise, I would just change it to something like “endurance” or “Strength of mind”.

When Zamorak penetrates your mind, it is not like the roll of a dice like when you attack an enemy!

==========

---“No need to stutter, just make your answer,” said Zamorak.
A long period of silence occurred between the both of you, as you thought of an answer. After much thinking and inner debate, you at last came to your answer.

Did you mean to put a space between the dialogue on the top row and the other two lines?

Also it includes some past tense.

==========

05-Mar-2009 16:42:50

[#CK2S64MN5]

[#CK2S64MN5]

Posts: 21 Bronze Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
btw good story not much i can tell you the "official review" pretty much covered grammar. O and if u keep writing 2nd person it might get repetitive because its not something you see a lot. i suggest changing it. Not sure why it is 2nd person

07-Mar-2009 02:01:02

Cozmic

Cozmic

Posts: 16,435 Opal Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
~~~~~~~~~~ The Novelists’ Guild ~~~~~~~~~~
~~Review of “DEATH” By Cicobe1 ~~

~~~~ Score ~~~~

Plot: 17/20
Description: 18/20
Originality/Thought: 19/20
Characters/Emotions: 18/20
Mechanics: 12/20

Total: 84%

~~~~ Reasons ~~~~

Plot: Great plot - it is well thought out and well executed. I enjoyed it emensely; many stories are quite boring, but this one pulls the reader in like a fish on a hook. The 'reaping' skill is clever, and a good idea; I enjoyed it.
Description: This is good, and increases in quality as the story progresses.
Originality/Thought: Quite original- though some elements have been done before.
Characters: They were good, though some of the dialogue was bad in the beginning.
Mechanics: Bad - simply bad. It gets better as you proceed, but you have NO excuse for the horrendous beginning.


~~~~ My thoughts ~~~~

Good, very good. It is a great story, the kind which draws you through the pages. It is very interesting, entertaining, and good. I enjoyed it, but your grammar is BAD.

~~~~ Summary ~~~~

Its all god except for the grammar.

~~~~ Corrected Errors ~~~~

I showed you enough above.

07-Mar-2009 05:20:29 - Last edited on 07-Mar-2009 05:20:42 by Cozmic

Cicobe1

Cicobe1

Posts: 4,823 Adamant Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
Yeah, I was planning to edit, but I idiotically asked for the review before my editing. I do have an excuse for the horrendous beginning - I didn't know what tenses were when I started. :P

Thanks for the review, and I know that the mechanics aren't a symbol of my "novelist" status.

:)

07-Mar-2009 18:13:31

Quick find code: 49-50-255-58364524 Back to Top