Forums

Zamorak's True Son

Quick find code: 49-50-112-44924638

Crystal Smee

Crystal Smee

Posts: 7,994 Rune Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
Characters and Development:
- Maybe you could play with the switch from being a regular Fremmenik to Zamorak’s son a little more – Put emotion into it. I mean, suddenly finding out you’re the son of a God is pretty big. Maybe at first he feels an impulse to go kill, then questions it, then gives in – you could add in some kind of internal struggle there.
- I don’t feel much emotion. He goes around killing people all the time – what does he feel like? Is he startled by his actions at first, repulsed, then feels overjoyed, excited, satisfied…what does he feel when he fights Sarah? Is he afraid? Confident. First person gives so many opportunities to get inside the character’s head, so you should capitalize on it.
- I like that he considers Jaldar and Zineryt his friends. – but maybe something make them closer…discussion outside of killing and destroying?
- Try not to overpower characters. It takes away from the realism of them – because some of the things your characters are doing are somewhat hard to believe.
- How did he just get to be Zamorak’s son? I don’t know if you were planning to reveal that at some point…But did his Relekkan parents take him in, or is son figurative, and Zamorak chose him to be this powerful person, or what?
Plot/Content:
- Things are moving a little quickly – we could have seen more of his life before, the story is just like ‘Okay now I’m evil and I kill people for fun.” – maybe have a whole chapter, like a day in the life, to emphasize the impact of suddenly becoming evil. Maybe from when he was younger, and he shows off violent tendencies or something…I dunno.
- The senseless killing and fighting is getting old, is there going to be any more plot to it than that? * It** repetitive.
- I like the banter and teasing between characters when they fight – always makes it more interesting. The taunts Saradomin and Zamorak throw at each other, and Zamak and Sarah too, it’s really funny.

16-Sep-2007 19:57:11

Crystal Smee

Crystal Smee

Posts: 7,994 Rune Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
- “I suddenly saw the fight between my friends and Sarah’s group.” – how?
- I get the feel that you write each fight scene of its own inspiration, without a specific end goal in mind – this goes with my previous question, will there be further plot? It feels like it needs more direction that this.
- ““Hold on,” Saradomin said, stopping the whole mood of watching a great fight. “I smell something.”
Zamorak lifted up his arm and smelled his armpits.” – HAH. That made me laugh. =)
- I love that you put Zamorak and Saradomin trapped together, forced to work together to get out – that is awesome. Incredible turn of events, and presents so many opportunities for more snappish, funny comments. =P Same for the other people fighting.
Organization:
- Thanks for putting up a table of contents, it’s really helpful.
- Make sure to start a new paragraph when switching speakers in dialogue – otherwise you can’t sometimes tell who is talking. This improves, but if you ever have the time, it’d be good to proofread the beginning.
Overall Comments: I read a lot of what Dreamweaver said, and I agreed with a lot of it, especially what he said about how you've improved. I think I said this in your other review too, I say this is many reviews - It's really clear how much you've grown as a writer over writing this story. Aside from that note, I enjoyed reading it, it's exciting. However, I think it could use touching up in grammar and description, and maybe some interesting plot twists such as the one you've left off at in your last add.

16-Sep-2007 20:00:16

The contents of this message have been hidden.

18-Sep-2007 07:41:16

Quick find code: 49-50-112-44924638 Back to Top