Forums

Zamorak's True Son

Quick find code: 49-50-112-44924638

Crystal Smee

Crystal Smee

Posts: 7,994 Rune Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
Hey, this is up next on my review list. =P I was just checking out the thread, and it seems like you haven't added in a while...It would be really helpful if you could give me an idea of where the adds end, just so I don't have to click through all the remaining pages looking for them. =)
Thanks. Expect a review later today, or tomorrow.
~ Smeeze ~

15-Sep-2007 18:14:20

Venmi

Venmi

Posts: 14,744 Opal Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
I just made a table of contents. It was a pain to make since there are so many posts (not story posts) on this popular thread.
*´¨)
¸.•´¸.•*´¨) ¸.•*¨)
(¸.•´ (¸.• (V)߆§¢‡, ¶@ï/\/ ÍÑ +|-|€ /\/£CK

15-Sep-2007 18:53:34

Crystal Smee

Crystal Smee

Posts: 7,994 Rune Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
Review for: Zamorak’s True Son, by Mbs**
Grammar/Spelling: This is messy in the beginning, mostly with the tense switches. There are still some places were commas could be added to make it read smoother, mostly in dialogue. Imagine how you would say the lines, maybe. Helps figure out comma placement for me. Your spelling however, is fine, and besides a few missing commas punctuation is fine.
- “trying to get what needed to be [done, done].” – prologue – I think this could use better wording, without the repeat of ‘done’. Maybe, “Trying to finish what needed to be done.” Or something along those lines.
- “Some were trying to sell warm [fish* that was [fished] during the fall, preserved for this season.” – same here – try not to repeat words within a sentence. “trying to sell warm fish that was caught” or something.
- “I [wondered] if they had anything to cool down this hellhole. I [see] a throne room roughly an eighth of a mile forward.” – Prologue – Switched tenses – You keep doing this mid-sentence and it’s really confusing. Pick past or present. I’d advise proofreading, the mistakes are extremely common in the first bit of the story.
Description/Vocab: I felt the imagery was a little lacking, especially in setting. It was often hard to visualize where they were. You use a lot of good vocabulary and describe fight scenes really well, but the setting is equally important and adds to the feeling of really being there, which draws the reader in. Working from first person, you can really just say, “I saw…” and list some of the things he sees. Try to remember to add a couple sentences whenever the characters move around.

16-Sep-2007 19:53:38

Crystal Smee

Crystal Smee

Posts: 7,994 Rune Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
- “I was dreaming about this very pretty girl roughly my age which is 16. My mom came up to my room and disturbed the silence.” – Show, don’t tell. – “I imagined long brown hair and dark copper skin, and her eyes, looking at me…” I dunno. I think it could be more interesting.
- ““Yes mom,” I said sulking.
After a rough day, I lied on my bed, sulking about all the hard work I had to do.” – try to use a variety of words to describe…Maybe scowled, frustrated, angry, upset…Again, this goes with repetition of words. This doesn’t flow badly, but, it could use more variety.
- “which was good because I was going to grab my father’s weapon, and kill everybody in Relleka, to be evil.” – Again with showing, not telling, you could build so much suspense with that. Have him take the sword and sneak out, but we don’t know why, then he suddenly stabs his mother and we’re like “OH!”
- Your simile of realization and a gnomeball – nice. I love when the similes relate to RS, too, it’s that much more creative. It was awesome.
- More setting description – what does hell look like? Describe the room he teleports to, you described his awe of the stars, now let him get a good look at his father’s home. Is it a cave, is it modernized, are there rooms or caverns, colors, random fires…?
- “All around, I saw a load of different armors, all of them looking nice.” – more. What kinds, what parts – mithril plates, rune legs, etc.
- ““Let me see,” I said, straining trying to find it.” – You could have more detail in the sensation of finding his magic. How does he find it? Does he run his senses through his body, what does it feel like when he finds it, is it warm/cold/tingly/painful, etc?

16-Sep-2007 19:54:13

Quick find code: 49-50-112-44924638 Back to Top