Forums

Poll poll

Quick find code: 380-381-63-65438225

Mod Ash

Mod Ash

Jagex Moderator Forum Profile Posts by user
FriskyDingo said :
Disgusting... I'm appalled that you've even listened to the ideas of the group of players in this game who want more restrictions on voting because they somehow believe it will lead to certain poll questions going in their favor.
Disgusting.

Mmhmm. If you make a list of all the players whose opinions we can listen to, do post it. Then all the other customers will know their opinions don't matter, so they can save themselves the hassle of posting.

Meanwhile, we have a 280 skill total requirement on the polls.
Maybe, if we had more flexibility about what the requirements were, we could remove the skill total requirement altogether, and replace it with a check for who's been spending time playing OSRS. Which is a lot closer to what you described in your post, where everyone who plays OSRS gets to vote, regardless of whether they get their levels up.
Or maybe you feel that the 280 requirement is perfect, and it's disgusting that I'd even be willing to admit I'd heard an alternative suggestion.

LV2 said :
Would we be able to possibly feature more polls with this, rather than having a large dev blog for small QOL updates that often don't get any explanation in the dev blog.

I assume we'd have the polling booths based on the polls current outcome, and if they had something to show that there were polls we hadn't voted on yet - or when we login it tells us there are new polls for us to vote on.

I think we'll still be locked to 1 poll running at a time. However, there's no rule saying they have to be very long ones with lots of questions. It's just a sight easier for us to coordinate polls - and to set aside some dev-time for offering bigger projects - if we don't have the polls running non-stop into each other.

There'll definitely be something to tell a player "There's a poll open in which you have not voted". I'd initially been thinking of using the MOTW for this, since it seldom shows anything very important. But we can do other things as well, or instead. If it's a poll booth, I'd be tempted to make it light up somehow for players who need to vote.

The one thing I'd like to avoid is a notification that looks like a pop-up advert.

28-Jul-2014 18:32:01 - Last edited on 28-Jul-2014 18:42:37 by Mod Ash

Mod Ash

Mod Ash

Jagex Moderator Forum Profile Posts by user
Bhaskar said :
If in game poll passes a poll at 75%, when would it come out?

Not sure. I gather the RS3 team were working on this sort of thing for weeks, going back and forth to the Engine team to get stuff tweaked. But it should be much easier for us - most of the tech issues got ironed out by the RS3 team.

Maybe 2-3 weeks after it's had its 75%-or-bust poll, depending on how much other stuff I'm busy doing first.

28-Jul-2014 18:49:03

FriskyDingo
Jun Member 2019

FriskyDingo

Posts: 2,595 Adamant Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
Mod Ash said :

if we had more flexibility about what the requirements were

Any OSRS account (meaning they've created their profile and gone through tutorial island) older than 3 months can vote. Similar to being 18 to vote (in USA atleast), that way you're getting people who've played the game for a good amount of time and not forcing anyone into getting a 280 total level.

28-Jul-2014 18:52:18 - Last edited on 28-Jul-2014 18:53:21 by FriskyDingo

Mod Ash

Mod Ash

Jagex Moderator Forum Profile Posts by user
FriskyDingo said :
Any OSRS account (meaning they've created their profile and gone through tutorial island) older than 3 months can vote. Similar to being 18 to vote (in USA atleast), that way you're getting people who've played the game for a good amount of time and not forcing anyone into getting a 280 total level.

The web team's previously told us they can't check account creation dates or login history. Just the skill total, and your F2P/member status.

In the blog, I've proposed that if we had in-game polls, we'd potentially be able to check other things instead. Account creation date currently isn't one of them, but it's something we'd like to get enabled anyway (because many people would like to know their account ages) so we could use it to run the checks you're describing, and then remove the 280 skill total requirement.

(Perhaps when you called the blog "disgusting" you were under the impression that we would obviously change the requirements upwards. But we'd need the exact same flexibility to be able to change them downwards.)

Now, I suspect there'll be a lot of people who'd oppose such a change, or who'd prefer us to change it in a different direction altogether.

We've actually got no plans whatsoever, at the moment, and unless there's a strong consensus about changing the poll rules, I'd be more inclined to leave them alone.

28-Jul-2014 19:06:49 - Last edited on 28-Jul-2014 19:08:24 by Mod Ash

Paladine

Paladine

Posts: 8,002 Rune Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
Mod Ash said :
FriskyDingo said :
Any OSRS account (meaning they've created their profile and gone through tutorial island) older than 3 months can vote. Similar to being 18 to vote (in USA atleast), that way you're getting people who've played the game for a good amount of time and not forcing anyone into getting a 280 total level.

The web team's previously told us they can't check account creation dates or login history. Just the skill total, and your F2P/member status.

In the blog, I've proposed that if we had in-game polls, we'd potentially be able to check other things instead. Account creation date currently isn't one of them, but it's something we'd like to get enabled anyway (because many people would like to know their account ages) so we could use it to run the checks you're describing, and then remove the 280 skill total requirement.

Now, I suspect there'll be a lot of people who'd oppose such a change, or who'd prefer us to change it in a different direction altogether.

We've actually got no plans whatsoever, at the moment, and unless there's a strong consensus about changing the poll rules, I'd be more inclined to leave them alone.


Off topic but can I just say how awesome the OSRS team is. You guys actually THINK about how to make the game fun. I see where your priorities lie. RS3 on the other hand... that recent lobby update squished useful information together just to make space for large microtransaction boxes.

28-Jul-2014 19:11:40

Paladine

Paladine

Posts: 8,002 Rune Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
Anyway, I really like the poll booths. Always nice to have something 'real', sort of like GE NPCs in RS3. They give the GE an authentic feel. But as people are on the go, I think bank pollers would be the best idea.

Not a fan of the newspaper - don't think a lot of people would waste one space for that. Tabs seem ok but it reminds me of RS3 with all their tabs as it's very cluttered. Even the new OSRS options are becoming a bit cluttery for my tastes but I understand they are essential - so I vote...

BANKS BANKS BANKS!

28-Jul-2014 19:18:42 - Last edited on 28-Jul-2014 19:19:42 by Paladine

Mod Ash

Mod Ash

Jagex Moderator Forum Profile Posts by user
Thanks :)

Paladine said :
Anyway, I really like the poll booths. Always nice to have something 'real', sort of like GE NPCs in RS3. They give the GE an authentic feel. But as people are on the go, I think bank pollers would be the best idea.

It looks, so far, like the bank thing will be the most popular.

28-Jul-2014 19:29:17

Saxo
Mar Member 2020

Saxo

Posts: 7,687 Rune Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
Paladine said :
Tabs seem ok but it reminds me of RS3 with all their tabs as it's very cluttered. Even the new OSRS options are becoming a bit cluttery for my tastes but I understand they are essential - so I vote...
I think it was just an option inside the settings tab, which is why I voted accept that one.. If it was a tab on its own I would have voted really like probably.

I just think if an in game poll system is going to get its own tab/area then it should be visible and easy to get to instead of jumping through hoops just to get to it.

Looks like the bank booth one will be happening anyway, preferred that one the most and it makes the most sense aswell as is easy to access without cluttering the place.

28-Jul-2014 19:39:45

Quick find code: 380-381-63-65438225 Back to Top