The cooking cape seems far more powerful than most of the others. I would suggest something more along the lines of having a chance to cook 2 fish simultaneously, granting XP for both as normal. Like you say in the criteria, it's a small bonus and only impacts the XP rate slightly, but it's still a useful little perk.
Also note that the second cooked food would always be cooked, and not simply be rolled for cooking or burning at the same time; this way you wouldn't just cook one and burn the other, which is basically pointless.
22-Sep-2015 00:34:29