Forums

DevBlog: Grand Exchange Tweaks

Quick find code: 380-381-141-65557333

Metal Little
Dec Member 2006

Metal Little

Posts: 2,377 Mithril Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
With that said, the GE will work only if one or more of the following are done:

1. Make it so that the GE doesn't formulate, price tag, or set prices (GE values) on items. By doing so, the price can't be easily manipulated, and players won't be coerced into buying or selling at the manipulated "market price" all the time. Also, players will maintain a great degree of control over prices rather than the system telling them a formulated buying or selling price. Instead, the GE or price checker should only provide a price range on an item. That would also eliminate the dreaded hassle of buying or selling at 5% over or under the market price. For example, the price of mind runes would show 3-5 GP instead of 4 GP.

2. Like the TP, the GE should show candidate offers from other players so that players can ultimately decide on the best offer rather than going gung-ho on a totally automated system.

3. Instead of a totally automated system, the GE should have a "Buy from Player X" and "Sell to Player X" option. Afterwards, the money or items can be collected from the collection box or the GE.

4. If players need to price an item, it should be done in the same manner as the GE. It should only include a price range (the minimum and maximum price) without giving an absolute value in a similar fashion as OS Buddy's price checker.

5. The only time the mean price, absolute value, or GE value of an item should be implemented is with Coin Share and Loot Share. Otherwise, buying and selling items should be based on a price range and players' willingness.

6. In the event of a newly-released item, again, no GE-suggested price or market value should be given. It should be entirely up to the players to determine the price range as will all items.

7. Lastly, make the GE accessible and available in every bank rather than in just one location. People claim the GE is convenient, but nothing is convenient about being limited to trading in one spot whereas the TP was in all banks.
~
Metal
~

Bring back the old look on male Armadyl armor!

52-time OSRS/3 Skill Master

19-Jan-2015 21:53:00

Misker Alex
Jan Member 2015

Misker Alex

Posts: 270 Silver Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
People who are saying add the Grand Exchange to the Wilderness. If anything, it shouldn't just be played in the Grid. When the Crater came in, the Hills were removed and Pures became very aggravated. If anything, an underground map wouldn't be so bad.

I was thinking of a Trading Post being in the Mage Bank itself, but in this one, if you are teleblocked, you shouldn't be able to use it.

Otherwise if it's going to be in every Bank, there should only be the Sell option at the Trading Posts. If you want to buy something, you'd have to buy it in the Trading Central which would be in North-West Varrock.

Should have buying and selling Limits to prevent overflow such as a 5,000 limit on Willow Logs. If people want to buy more at that time, they could meet up in person and trade it.

19-Jan-2015 21:58:18

Raemonde

Raemonde

Posts: 391 Silver Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
The Grand Exchange should have a central building in north-west Varrock

and be the same as the old Grand Exchange! that is a great design and no good Reason to Change it for some thing inferior we voted for "THE GRANDE EXCHANGE" not for a weak copy!

19-Jan-2015 22:00:37

Red partyhat
Jun Member 2023

Red partyhat

Posts: 1,505 Mithril Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
Cant help but feel that this wouldn't have passed if there wasn't so much influence from the "Famous" Runescape Streamers/videomakers. I seem to recall the Grand Exchange being polled quite a while ago and it failed, But that's before video makers all jumped on Twitch and ordered their cattle to vote yes.

19-Jan-2015 22:02:13 - Last edited on 19-Jan-2015 22:11:16 by Red partyhat

Lewis Shoot
Oct Member 2005

Lewis Shoot

Posts: 3,825 Adamant Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
First off, I am not against the grand exchange but I do feel it shouldn't be used in Old School. Now obviously it's passed a poll which had a record amount of votes leading me to suspect some sort of jiggery pokery, especially because the Old School team really pushed it onto us without giving the trading post much time. They more or less made the trading post seem bigger in order to disappoint players and increase popularity of the GE. However I guess there is no point arguing about that now.
Rant gone. It's passed and now we need to refine it so it doesn't completely mess us up even more than expected.

Location:
Falador: It'd be nice, however trading was pushed out from there years ago and I can't see where it could be placed without messing up the look of the park or completely remodelling the park.
Varrock: It's well established, however people associate it with rs3 so there could be people hating that.
Every bank: Now this would make it too easy, if we are the have a GE we should at least show some effort to go to a location and socialise with each other.
Everybank + a central location: I seriously can't imagine the central location having any/many players there. There are many banks that are closer to teleports and people would just use those.
RIP Forums :(
Finally we have signatures in the surprise forum update. I'm Lewis, I play Old School & I've been playing since 2005.

19-Jan-2015 22:12:41 - Last edited on 19-Jan-2015 22:13:27 by Lewis Shoot

Lewis Shoot
Oct Member 2005

Lewis Shoot

Posts: 3,825 Adamant Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
Herbs:
Grimy herbs last had 52% support when you polled it, this isn't even a near miss. I understand the need to show which herbs people are buying but when you're buying herbs you never really want to clean them, you only want to create potions with them. There are a few cases were cleaning/identifying herbs has been profitable but it's not worth introducing grimy herbs just for that.
You could possibly make it so herbs have to be identified then cleaned in order to be used in potions, but that'd basically be the same item and would be redundant.

Jewelry decanter:
It's a lovely idea, I'd love a guy who charges a bit of money for this. I'd also like this to be added as spell (lunar or standard).
Potion decanter:
We already have one of these, so I feel this guy is more redundant. However I was surprised to find he doesn't charge money for his services.
Note: Where will the decanters go if the GE is available in every bank?
RIP Forums :(
Finally we have signatures in the surprise forum update. I'm Lewis, I play Old School & I've been playing since 2005.

19-Jan-2015 22:12:44 - Last edited on 19-Jan-2015 22:16:12 by Lewis Shoot

Gad Zook

Gad Zook

Posts: 1,883 Mithril Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
If you just spent the last year complaining we "need grand exchange" because you don't like world 1 varrock, how in hell can you now insist on having the original setup? Moving the sheep 200 feet northwest but still having them crammed in the same spot is stupid. Break it up.

19-Jan-2015 22:19:58

Quick find code: 380-381-141-65557333 Back to Top