My sole fear with achievement diaries is overpowered rewards. At the time I quit there were only Varrock/Fally/Kara diaries. Falador gave the insane cabbage ring - all of its powers were very useful, two of them extremely so (seriously, that teleport, if it were in a spellbook, would've been one of the most useful ones, and it was given -freely-).
The really troublesome part was that the ring slot is otherwise useless. What're you gonna wear there, a ring of life? Of forging? The fally ring completely obliterated all competition. If it were a platebody/leg, there would've been some choice to it, but having those powers on a ring was a massive power jump for the ring slot. The ring may have been balanced compared to other achievement rewards (it wasn't, it was by far the best), but that's like introducing a cape with +50 slash +40 strength because there's an achievement scimitar with similar stats on it, completely ignoring that other capes don't come anywhere near..
Also, daily **** is ****.
02-Nov-2014 16:04:43