I'm going to have to go with The Chosen Commander. While I greatly enjoyed some aspects of other quests, Such as the epicness of Dragon Slayer when f2p, The Chosen Commander was the best representation of "questing done right".
Even though there are quests like Fate of the Gods, While Guthix Sleeps, and Branches of Darkmeyer, The Chosen Commander was a true finale that didn't disappoint (I'm counting The Mighty Fall as an Epilogue here).
While it's true that The Void Stares Back was also a finale, filled with the always appreciated ability to make choices and decisions, the quest series has less of a build up compared to the lineage of The Lost Tribe to The Chosen Commander(5 quests versus 3). Also, at the time Zanik's crossbow was a decent weapon, so it had a good reward and an excellent story (while The Void Stares Back had a great reward, Korasi's sword, and a very good story).
I also enjoyed The Chosen Commander, as it was not overly challenging at the time(This is also why I wouldn't consider Nomad's Requiem to be that great. It was essentially "enter the dungeon and kill the boss", like high stakes dungeoneering).
With Plague's End, I hope that an immense amount of effort is put into the story of the elves, Priffdinas, and the dark lord and not just into the boss fight and puzzles. Too much or a boss fight and you get Nomad's Requiem or The Mighty Fall, yet if there is too much of a puzzle aspect, you get an Elemental Workshop III.
02-Aug-2014 10:57:36