Hey there, I'd like to point out something with the Observatory quest.
As a player trying to keep 45 Defense, I am now faced with a difficult decision because of this quest and it's reward system. Even with a 1 in 12 chance, I was still assigned the constellation Virgo, which gives 875 Defense experience as a reward. This is rather problematic for people in my position, as I was looking forward to completing the Varrock Hard Achievements while staying 45 Defense.
Having a randomly generated reward that forces people to decide whether they want to complete the quest and become a main, or not and miss out on some benefits that otherwise would have been available to them had they just been slightly luckier, strikes me as rather silly and unfair to those with poor luck.
My suggestion would be to simply remove the need for a correct answer at the end of the quest. Allow people to simply choose which constellation they saw, and not force the decision on them.
26-Dec-2016 13:20:00