While there are many problems that people are associating with this, I do believe that it is a very good idea that many players (Old and new) are excited about. I don't personally find it a problem that I will have to start from scratch, it will just be a large overdose of Nostalgia that I'd be sure to enjoy.
However, the only problem I see in this is the lack of members actually voting for this to pass through. If every member voted "Yes", they would suffer no casualties to their game. Jagex would still update the main game frequently, as they stated. If every Member would click "Yes" as opposed to "No", they would just be helping out the veteran players, with no real casualty on their end.
Another problem that is linked to the above problem is the amount of Veterans there are from 2007 compared to how many there are now. A lot of the Veterans have long since, quit *he game. Many of them remain as Free players, and have the FaceBook page "Like" 'd, along with some other method to receive news from Jagex. However, I feel that not many votes will be accumulated due to the fact that a lot of us that want servers dedicated to 2007, don't have Memberships anymore.
If Jagex could find a way to include a portion of "Free" players to vote for this grand idea, I do believe that we have a more fair chance of getting the servers.
These problems aside I do believe that this is indeed the moment I've been waiting a very long time for. If this feature is passed,(With a maximum of $5 extra on the membership) you can count on me buying it as soon as possible.
Let's hope that these Servers will arrive with a cheap price tag!
13-Feb-2013 21:32:49